Saturday, October 8, 2011

Fred Nile's History of Australia

Greece gave us Herodotus. Rome, Tacitus. England, Gibbon. Australia, Fred Nile.

From Your Kingdom Come 080808, A New Day for Australia's Prayer Gathering at yourkingdomcome.com.au. The highlights are mine. The delights all yours:

"1. AUSTRALIA's PROPHETIC ROLE IN WORLD AFFAIRS

(a) Australia's title - 'The Great South Land of the Holy Spirit', and Southern Cross in the sky above Australia.
(b) Australia's beginning in modern history. A dumping ground for convicts who were reformed and renewed.
(c) First evangelical Minister with the First Fleet - RICHARD JOHNSON, who laid evangelical foundations.

"2. WORLD WAR I

(a) Gallipoli - miraculous evacuation with not one casualty.
(b) Beersheba - Australia's Light Horse victory over Turkish Muslim Fortress.
(c) Jerusalem - Victory opened the door for the liberation of Jerusalem, which climaxed with the formation of Israel in 1948. (ZEPHANIAH 3:14-15 'HE HAS CAST OUT YOUR ENEMY'.)

"3. WORLD WAR II

(a) Australian victory at El Alamein Egypt, over Rommel's Africa Corp.
(b) First victories against Japanese Army in Malaya and New Guinea - Kokoda Trail.
(c) KOREA - Royal Australian Regiment stopped and delayed Communist Chinese advance.
(d) VIETNAM - Australian victory at LONG TAN.
(e) GULF WARS - Australian SAS destroyed SCUD Missiles aimed at Israel.
(f) IRAQ - Liberation of Iraq.
(g) AFGHANISTAN - Defeated Taliban Islamic Regime.
(h) EAST TIMOR - Defeated Muslim Militia, restored democratic Government.

"As a small nation, Australia has made an important impact on World Affairs in the providence of God."

Bonus offering from the above document: Fred reckons Australia faces "serious challenges." Could the last of the seven he lists be the most serious of the lot?: "Opposing the growing power and influence of 1 billion Muslims who are forcing their religious-political ideology, based on the Koran on Western Christian nations including Australia because it is an anti-Christ, which was formed by a false prophet Mohammed. (1 John 2: 20-26, 4:1-3, 4:15)."

Friday, October 7, 2011

Witches Brew 5

The Reverend Fred Nile of the openly Islamophobic Christian Democrats was practically beside himself in support of David Clarke's 15 September anti-BDS motion in the NSW Legislative Council. But first, he just had to say hello to his beaming mates sitting in the gallery:

"I also acknowledge the representatives of the Jewish Board of Deputies in the gallery and thank them for their support. Some members of the House are Jewish and I do not think the rest of us can fully comprehend the impact that an attack of this type would have on Jewish people. As a non-Jew, I wish to identify with the Jewish people at this time and sympathise with them for the strong feeling of revulsion that these types of campaigns cause in the hearts of every Jewish person."

Now for those who don't already know, Fred's got quite a track record when it comes to Jews (Good!) and Muslims (Bad! Really, really baaad!). He's the guy reportedly behind the virulent opposition to a Muslim school in Camden in Sydney's south-west (Nile party behind anti-Muslim school rally, Wendy Frew, SMH, 21/12/07); whose election slogans have included 'No nukes for Iran - we must defend Israel', and 'Ten-year moratorium on Muslim immigration'. (Nile raises crusade in by-election, Imre Salusinszky, The Australian, 6/11/09); whose campaign manager's son, CDP member Douglas Darby, was caught out sending emails telling Muslims, whom he claimed "habitually engage in child molestation, incest [and] pack rape," to "obey the laws of this country or f..k off to Afghanistan where Australians are allowed to shoot you people." (Obscene anti-Muslim emails put Nile on the defensive, Sean Nicholls, SMH, 21/11/09); and who thought so highly of a speech by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that he actually read it out in the NSW Parliament (Long may Israel live!, cdp.org.au, 22/6/11)

But, to really get a deeper insight into CDP 'thinking', especially on the subject of Israel, the potted bio of Fred's Parliamentary Secretary, Judith (Judy) Russell, at christianworldview.org.au is hard to beat:

"Judy is the great granddaughter of Maud & Donald McBean, Donald being a Light Horseman... who saw service in Palestine (now Israel) in 1917, in particular Beer Sheba. Judy's delight in knowing her great grandfather was involved in the liberation of Jerusalem from Ottoman rule, thus paving the way for the rebirth of Israel in 1948, enhances her zeal and love for Israel and the continuing covenants all made by God with Israel. Judy has had 4 tours of Israel and looks forward to others, as the Lord leads. Her tours are specifically tailored to see what the Lord is doing today in Israel and interacting with the Jewish people... Judy has a passion for the Scriptures and in particular seeing the Lord's prophetic plans come to pass. Through her private studies she has found the entire Bible is a love story between God and His chosen people, Israel. The Church, born after the death and resurrection of our Lord Jesus Christ, had to wait until Acts 10 where the gentiles were grafted into the Jewish root, via the precious blood of our Jewish Messiah. Judy gives thanks and praise to God for placing her in the strategic position in the NSW Parliament. It is with gratitude to Rev Fred and Hon Elaine Nile whose dedication and faithfulness opened the way for the CDP to have a place in the NSW Parliament that we have such opportunities to host so many Christian, pro Israel functions and activities."

Whether Fred & Co think we're all on the road to Armageddon (tellingly a question no journalist or researcher that I'm aware of has ever bothered asking) I don't know, but if Judy's theological musings and rambles among the chosen don't set off the warning signs, I don't know what will. Anyway, I digress. Back to Fred's speech:

"I believe that we should not be in any way tolerant of this campaign but reject it absolutely and stop it in its tracks. It is a most evil activity and one that should not be tolerated. I mentioned in my adjournment speech what happened in Germany. Probably, in some people's minds, they were just watching stormtroopers standing outside various businesses that were owned by Jewish people, stopping customers from entering those shops. The Nazis tested public opinion and, when there was no reaction, they moved to the next stage of closing those shops, smashing shop windows and so on. Then we had what the Nazis regarded as the final solution, which was taking Jewish people to concentration camps and removing them from the face of the Earth. That was the end of their campaign. We cannot be tolerant of even the smallest beginnings of this anti-Semitic campaign."

Stone the crows! You have landed on Max Brenner. Go straight to the Final Solution.

On the anti-BDS smear and loathing scale (see my 13/9/11 post Smear & Loathing), that'd only require references to lampshades made of human skin and soap from body fat to make it a ten-out-of-ten smear. And this clown draws a taxpayer-funded salary of over $233,000!

There is no God.

Wednesday, October 5, 2011

The Peace Team: Politics & PR

"In order to disseminate an image [of itself], a government can employ what was originally labeled as propaganda. Following the harmful yet effective propaganda that was in circulation throughout the Second World War and the following Cold War, such image-shaping efforts have now been renamed in order to avoid the negative connotations. Governments now talk about 'public diplomacy'. Public diplomacy can affect the foreign policy of another country and thus influence their treatment towards one's own country. While this can be done through diplomatic, economic and military means, it can also be achieved through 'soft power'. Therefore governments target civilian audiences whose opinion has a bearing on the government's policy... In this way, outside governments began to realise that they can have a positive effect on the opinion of civilians and, in turn, on that country's foreign policy through carefully grooming their public image and explaining their actions to the rest of the world through information... The Israeli government takes the role of public diplomacy very seriously and as such devotes a number of resources to educating and influencing foreign audiences, particularly those in the United States. The Israeli government has its own word that has been used since the 1970s in relation to their own public diplomacy work. Hasbara is roughly translated as 'explanation' and is used in the context of Israeli policy and actions." (Israel: Propaganda, public diplomacy & soft power, Harriet Straughen, paltelegraph.com, 10/5/11)

One Israeli practitioner of 'public diplomacy', the so-called Peres Centre for Peace (PPC), has hit on the PR tactic of fielding joint Israeli/Palestinian sporting teams designed to mask and obfuscate the brutal reality of the Israeli occupation and colonisation of Palestine's indigenous inhabitants.

Its Australian representative, Tanya Oziel, who breezily talks of bringing together "athletes from the two war-torn nations" (one of whom is a tad more war-torn than the other) and "breaking down barriers" (apartheid walls and checkpoints notwithstanding) has been busy since 2008 in promoting tours to Australia by an Israeli/Palestinian AFL 'Peace Team'. The Peace Team not only played in the 2008 AFL International Cup, but, for maximum public exposure, it became the subject of a film, Tackling Peace, screened on Channel 10 in 2009. (See Tanya Oziel honoured, sportingpulse.com)

This year, the promotion of the Peace Team - which is to say Israel - in the Australian press has become the pet project of Age sports journalist Martin Flanagan, who has so far produced at least 4 promos on the subject.

Flanagan is an interesting case, apparently atypical of so many of our Israel-bound journalist junketeers. One is reminded of Humbert Wolfe's cheeky little rhyme: "You cannot hope to bribe or twist/Thank God! The British journalist/But, seeing what the man will do/Un-bribed there's no occasion to."

In his first piece on the Peace Team in June, Flanagan was at pains to explain just how pure his motives were:

"A few months ago I had reason to reflect on my own mortality and realised that the cause which interested me most... is peace. I realise, to some people, peace is an empty word. Perhaps it is best understood by considering its opposite - war, particularly as it is fought nowadays, with lots of civilian casualties. Children with limbs blown off, that sort of thing. I think war is hell. I'm not a pacifist, but do think there are people who carry peace with them through the world and they have my undying respect. I've gone to Israel for 10 days. I'm part of a delegation led by Tanya Oziel, the woman who organised the Palestinian-Israeli football team that competed in the AFL International Cup 3 years ago and is preparing to return. For the record, I am paying my airfares but my accommodation is being sponsored by the PPC..." (Peace is more than just a word, 25/6/11)

As you can see, Flanagan's bought into the PPC's propagandist notion of a 'war' between two 'sides', akin to a game played between two evenly-matched football teams. It may be the case, to adapt the adage that to a hammer everything looks like a nail, that to Flanagan, the blinkered sports journalist, every conflict from World Wars I and II on down looks like a football game, including the utterly asymmetrical struggle between Israeli coloniser and Palestinian colonised. So, whatever his illusions about promoting the Peace Team, he's well and truly party to the PPC's monstrous misrepresentation of reality.

Flanagan further compounds this misrepresentation with such faux profundities as: "I know I'm going to a deeply troubled region. I also know I'm going to a powerful land. Three great religious dreamings emanate in one way or another from there."

Israelis and Palestinians, he'd have us believe, are really just kids with 'issues' from a tough neighbourhood. So don't bother your boofhead with the actual, ongoing colonial dynamic of Israel's relentless campaign of dispossession and ethnic cleansing, just bring the lads "from two of the most violently conflicted groups on earth" together as a team, watch them get whipped by Nauru (which, incidentally, routinely votes for Israel in the UN), and finally have coach Robert 'Dipper' DiPierdomenico farewell them with these edifying words: "'I'll miss you f...ing blokes. We gotta stay in touch. When you play footy with someone, you might not see 'em for years. Then you see 'em walking down the street and say, 'F..., what are you doing?'." After that you can go home, pretending you've brought peace in the Middle East just that little bit closer when all you've really done is slap a bit of lippy on Israel's apartheid pig.

I'd like to think that some readers of Flanagan's often maudlin drivel can see through it, but if the following response is anything to go by, the PPC will have gotten its money's worth. It comes from the notreallyaustralian blog:

"Read editorial written by Martin Flanagan. After reading it, I was curious [as] to who Flanagan was. So I asked Lord Wiki. He's a journalist who writes a sports column. He's also the brother of Richard Flanagan, the Tassie author. I should have suspected that. The editorial was about the Palestinian-Israeli football team. Flanagan and some others are going to Israel to meet the players. Flanagan is impressed with the whole business, and so am I. I don't often have a lot of understanding about why Palestinians and Israeli's [sic] hatefully and violently fight over a tiny piece of land. Flanagan is more understanding than me. 'I know I am going to a deeply troubled region. I also know I am going to a powerful land. Three great religious dreamings emanate in one way or another from there'. Flanagan uses the term power of place. I think for some Jews and Palestinians, there IS a power of place. For others, I think the power of place comes out of the animosity towards the other group. It reminds me of the time that Jack came to the lake house with fake cat vomit. He showed it to his cousins, and they played together. Then suddenly, there was a huge tearful fight over the cat vomit. My sister and I were dragged into the drama. Suddenly, we realised that this was cat vomit we were talking about; and it all seemed so silly. No, I am not saying that Israel is like cat vomit. I am just saying that sometimes we cling to something simply for the fact that other people are clinging to it as well. I'd say for many Jews... they hate Palestinians more than they love Israel. And for many Palestinians, I bet they hate Jews more than they love their land of Palestine. I think the Palestinians and Jews who reach out to each other and try to make peace... I think they're the ones who truly love the land of Israel." (That weird American who's obsessed with Australia: Peace, Ministry of Magic, Clergymen, & Age, 26/6/11)

You can see the kind of damage Flanagan's folderol is doing out there.

Now I wish I could say that his June piece was a one-off, but I can't. In July he was at it again, telling us that:

"I went to Israel to find peace. People I told said, 'Funny place to go'. Our Tel Aviv hotel was on the beach across the road from the nightclub blown up by a suicide bomber in 2001; 21 died, one as young as 14. In front of the wreckage is a sculpture, rough-hewn from steel. It has two shapes, one male, one female, and in Hebrew the words: 'We will never stop dancing'." (Finding peace in an unlikely place, 2/7/11)

Except that Israelis are not dancing in the occupied Palestinian territories of the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza. Shooting, raiding, arresting, imprisoning, torturing, bulldozing, evicting, dispossessing, and colonising, yes, but definitely not dancing.

In August came an account of a PPC event which brought together students from Melbourne's Bialik College and "youths" from Newport Mosque. Flanagan, of course, regaled them with the story of St Tanya ("the woman who had this crazy idea of taking Australian football to the Middle East as a peace initiative") and 'her' Peace Team. After which they all sat back and watched the film Tackling Peace and listened to a nice policeman discussing such things as "empathy" and "respect" and "seeing things from other people's viewpoint as well as your own." Flanagan concluded, naturally, with a paragraph advertising the next public appearance of the Peace Team. (Saturday Reflection, 20/8/11)

Finally, in September, came another round of applause for the "brilliant" Tanya and this glowing tribute to the Peace Team's Israeli members:

"When I told my Jewish dentist that some of the Israelis in the Peace Team were great blokes, he smiled and said, 'Why wouldn't the Israelis be great blokes?' to which I replied, There are blokes, good blokes and great blokes. I'm saying there were some great israeli blokes in the team'. They were the men I admired because to me they had a full consciousness of the reality in their country and were trying to find a new approach to it. One of them, Nimrod, the son of an Israeli female lieutenant-general, had fought in two wars. He was a very smart young man with inner composure who was concerned about the morality of the conflict. When the Peace Team had its first internal dialogue, Nimrod said to the Palestinians: 'Let's do a deal. We're going to do one some day. Let's do it now'." (Without politics, Peace Team is peaceful, 24/9/11)

Top blokes all! But the Palestinians? Why, it's enough to break Flanagan's heart:

"It is no secret that Palestinians generally did not support the Peace Team, believing it masked the reality of their political situation. A number of Palestinian players were threatened. One was under cyber attack the whole time he was in Australia. The attacks continued after his return to his home in the West Bank. This week he pulled out of the Peace Team."

Maybe, just maybe, Palestinians know something our PR man doesn't. But, of course, Flanagan doesn't want to go there:

"Personally," says he, "I don't want to get involved in the politics of the Middle East."

Martin, maaate, don't pee on our legs and tell us it's raining, ok?

Related posts: Sport Rots the Brain (19/8/11); Foul Play (17/6/11)

Tuesday, October 4, 2011

Dishonest Broker, 1921

In 1917, a bunch of upper class twits in top hats, collectively known as His Brittanic Majesty's Government, were in the thick of a right royal dustup with their German rivals. Finding themselves in a rather tight corner with Fritz, they foolishly succumbed* to the smooth talk of a certain Mr Chaim Weizmann of the British Zionist Organisation, who intimated both that his 'people' packed a pretty powerful punch and that if Britain wouldn't deliver what he wanted, that is, a Jewish state - sorry, homeland - in Palestine, then Fritz would* - know what I mean? - and so, in the mother-of-all brainsnaps, the top hats issued that Devil of All Promises, the Balfour Declaration.

It came in 2 parts: "His Majesty's Government view with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people, and will use their best endeavours to facilitate the achievement of this object, it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of the existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine..."

The Palestinian Arabs, of course, insofar as they were thought of at all (after all, were they not merely the existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine?), were expected to be deliriously happy with the latter clause as a guarantee of their interests.

[* See my 12/4/11 post Only in The Australian.]

Not unnaturally, they smelt a rat and sent a delegation to London in August 1921 to try to head off the history with which we are now only too sickeningly familiar. Unfortunately, as that Palestinian delegation discovered, and as every Palestinian delegation since has discovered, when dealing with imperial knaves and fools, not to mention their Zionist urgers, all you're ever going to get really is the rough end of the proverbial pineapple.

The story of that first Palestinian delegation and its reception comes from Doreen Ingrams' incomparable Palestine Papers: 1917-1922: Seeds of Conflict (1972), a book that allows "the original documents culled from the secret minutes of Cabinet meetings, and from the telegrams and memos of ministers, generals, ambassadors and the Intelligence Services" to speak for themselves. Read it, learn why the Middle East is in such a godawful mess today, and weep:

"The Cabinet met to discuss the [Churchill] Memorandum on 18 August. The minutes recorded that: 'The Cabinet were informed that recent reports from Palestine were of a disturbing character. Arabs and Jews were armed... and a conflict might shortly ensue, particularly if the Moslem-Christian Delegation, now in London, returned without having secured the withdrawal of Mr Balfour's pledge to the Zionists. The latter were naturally anxious as to their position, and wished to be reassured as to the Government's support. Two courses were open to the Cabinet. They could withdraw from their Declaration, refer the Mandate back to the League of Nations, set up an Arab National Government, and slow down or stop the immigration of Jews: or they could carry out the present policy with greater vigour and encourage the arming of the Jews with a view later on of reducing the numbers of the British garrison and cutting down expenses. A draft pronouncement prepared by Dr Weizmann was read, for which he desired official approval, but objection was taken to its terms, and, in particular, to placing the control of immigration in the hands of the Jews... In the course of the discussion which followed, stress was laid on the following considerations: (i) The honour of the Government was involved in the Declaration made by Mr Balfour, and to go back on our pledge would seriously reduce the prestige of this country in the eyes of Jews throughout the world... (iv) On the other hand, it was urged that peace was impossible on the lines of the Balfour Declaration, which involved setting up a National Home for the Jews and respecting the rights of the Arab population. The result of this inconsistency must be to estrange both Arabs and Jews, while involving us in futile expenditure. Against this position it was argued that the Arabs had no prescriptive right to a country which they had failed to develop to the best advantage'.

"Soon after the Arab delegation arrived in London the members were received by Hubert Young at the Colonial Office. Young made a note of their conversation: 'They started by asking for the immediate establishment of a responsible Government in Palestine on an elective basis; for the abrogation of the Balfour Declaration, for the repeal of all legislation passed by the British authorities since the occupation, for the re-establishment of Ottoman law and for the suspension of all immigration until the National Assembly was formed and could pass its own laws. It did not take long to convince them of the absurdity of some of these proposals and the unlikelihood of others being adopted. They then began to state their case more reasonably. They said that their experience in Palestine during the last year had proved to them that the Balfour Declaration was self-contradictory and that the establishment of a National Home for the Jews in that country was utterly inconsistent with the safeguarding of the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities... they criticised the specially favoured position of the Zionist Organisation in the mandate: the appointment of Sir Herbert Samuel and Mr Bentwich to the chief executive and legislative posts in the administration: the recognition of Hebrew as an official language: the rise in the cost of living and effect on the labour market produced by the immigration of Jews: the importation of Bolsheviks into Palestine..'.

"'I pointed out to them that... all these criticisms were merely repetitions of their objections to the Zionist policy and none of them really provided instances of a breach of the second clause of the Balfour Declaration. So long as the policy of His Majesty's Government was a Zionist policy they must expect administrative measures to be more flavoured with Zionism than they would have been if no such policy existed... I... eventually got them to do what I had all along hoped they would do, which was to ask how we imagined that the Zionist policy could ever be carried out without prejudice to the rights of the non-Jews. I said that this was exactly what we were anxious to explain to them, and that we were ready, if they desired it, to put them in touch with the Zionist Organisation so that they could get some idea of the concrete schemes which are now being considered for the economic development of the country. They said that they would prefer to be re-assured by the Government which had adopted the policy rather than by the people whose demands had been met by it. They said with some force that even if His Majesty's Government could evolve a method of carrying out the Balfour Declaration with equal fairness to all parties there was clearly no possibility of reconciling the repeated claims made by the Zionists that Palestine should be as Jewish as England was English with the preservation of their own rights. I asked them to judge our policy, not by what the Jews said, but by what we did. I promised that any verified instance of the second clause of the Balfour Declaration having been set aside would immediately be investigated'.

"In September the Delegation went to Geneva which had become the headquarters of the League of Nations... The Arab Delegation after conducting 'a long siege' succeeded in meeting Balfour 'who spoke to them with graceful and studied vagueness of the 'experiment' of Zionism. It was their only meeting with him. They returned to London in the autumn'.

"On 7 November John Shuckburgh wrote a note to Sir James Masterton-Smith on the possibility of holding a joint conference of the Arabs and Zionists: 'If the Secretary of State agrees to a joint conference I think it is important to arrange that his speech should be interpreted to the Arabs paragraph by paragraph, as it is delivered... Hardly any of them understand English, and the effect of the speech will be much diminished if it conveys no impression to them at the moment of delivery... I should like to add a word about policy... The Zionist Organisation, in the person of Dr Weizmann, enjoys direct access to high political personages outside the Colonial Office. Dr Weizmann told me recently that he had asked the Prime Minister orally not very long ago... what meaning His Majesty's Government had attached to the phrase 'Jewish National Home' in the famous Balfour Declaration. The Prime Minister replied: 'We meant a Jewish state', and I understand that Mr Balfour, who was present on the occasion, corroborated the Prime Minister's statement. I do not know what may have been the original intention, but it was certainly the object of Sir Herbert Samuel and the Secretary of State to make it clear that a Jewish state was just what we did not mean. It is clearly useless for us to endeavour to lead Dr Weizmann in one direction, and to reconcile him to a more limited view of the Balfour pledge, if he is told a quite different story by the head of the government. Nothing but confusion can result if His Majesty's Government do not speak with a single voice..'.

"A meeting of the Arabs and the Zionists was arranged for 29 November but the Secretary of State [Churchill] did not appear: instead they were received by Shukburgh. Weizmann gave an account of the meeting in a letter to Wyndham Deedes in Palestine, in which he described it as a failure, laying the blame on the lack of proper preparation... He then went on in his letter to blame the majority of the British in Palestine (nine-tenths of whom he considered to be against the Zionists) for the attitude of the Arabs, who thought there was no need to negotiate as they could achieve their aim by misrepresentation and anti-Semitic propaganda... There were also official accounts of the meeting between the Arabs and Zionists. Eric Mills... recorded that: '... Shukburgh suggested that both parties should leave the region of abstract politics and discuss concrete realities, and he offered two points upon which he invited the parties to give their views: (1) The real fear with which the Arabs regarded the idea of Jewish Immigration (2) The real fear with which they regarded the contingency of Jewish political ascendancy in Palestine... Mussa Kazim Pasha el Husseini stated that the Arab Delegation had already forwarded the idea of a proper solution to the problem of Palestine. Mr Shukburgh pointed out that the solution in question could not be the basis of discussion because His Brittanic Majesty's Government insisted on adherence to the Balfour Declaration'.

"'Dr Weizmann... insisted that Zionism meant no encroachment upon the legitimate political aspirations of the indigenous Arabs. He might, if he had chosen, have concentrated upon measures which would have resulted in Palestine being divided into two - one half purely Jewish the other purely Arab. But that solution was not to the advantage of Palestine and he preferred to treat the future Palestine as a country where the two nations could live in political harmony and related reciprocally as Palestinian citizens... In any case he took his stand on the Draft Mandate the principles of which were unalterable..'.

"'Mussa Kazim el Husseini replied that the Delegation had already informed His Britannic Majesty's Government that the Draft Mandate was unacceptable, and had also protested to the League of Nations against its terms. They did not understand the meaning of the Balfour Declaration. Why could not His Britannic Majesty's Government give a clear interpretation so that Arabs might know where they were? In the present circumstances they were unable to discuss anything at all since they knew not what to discuss'.

"'Mr Shuckburgh informed the Delegation that the Draft Mandate must stand but it might be possible to offer a new formula in regard to the substance of the Balfour declaration and its corollary the Draft Mandate. Supposing that it were possible to draw up a formula of this kind as a basis of discussion would the Arabs be willing to enter discussion again?... The Delegation replied that they would welcome another interpretation... but the Government were to remember that the Draft Mandate was quite repugnant..'.

"Shuckburgh wrote a Note on the meeting...: '... The discussion lasted two hours and was, on the whole, conducted with good temper on both sides. The upshot was that Dr Weizmann offered to enter into direct discussion with the Arabs on the two main points raised by me, viz: (1) Limitation of Jewish immigration (2) Constitutional safeguards against Jewish political ascendency. The Arabs did not accept this offer, although I appealed to them to do so... I am afraid that the results of the meeting are rather negative in character, but it is at least something to have brought the two parties together..'.

"Eric Mills commented on Shukburgh's note: 'Dr Weizmann, while his speech was conciliatory, adopted an unfortunate manner in delivering it. His attitude was of the nature of a conqueror handing to beaten foes the terms of peace. Also I think he despises the members of the delegation as not worthy protagonists - that it is a little derogatory to him to expect him to meet them on the same ground. It seems to me that it is quite hopeless to expect Arabs and Zionists to meet on common ground when that ground is already occupied by His Britannic Majesty's Government on the Balfour Declaration, no matter what be the interpretation of that Declaration and no matter in what forms its substance is embodied..'." (pp 143-150)

Plus ca change, plus c'est la meme chose.

Monday, October 3, 2011

Lyons Contradicts Van Onselen at The Australian

Peter Van Onselen, The Australian's rambammed contributing editor writing on Robert Manne's Quarterly Essay critique of his paper in last Saturday's edition:

"Manne's conspiracy that at The Australian the tail wags the dog - editorial policy shaping news gathering - is overstated." (Manne allows ideology to cloud his judgments)

John Lyons, The Australian's Middle East correspondent, toes the paper's pro-Israel editorial line while 'reporting' Abbas' and Netanyahu's recent UN speeches in the same edition:

"Since the barbaric Palestinian campaign of killing civilians in the second intifada... only 8 years ago, Israelis distrust Palestinians." (Netanyahu, Abbas hail wins but victories Pyrrhic at best)

"'I come before you today from the Holy Land, the land of Palestine, the land of divine messages, ascension of the prophet Mohammed (peace be upon him) and the birthplace of Jesus (peace be upon him), to speak on behalf of the Palestinian people'. To an Israeli audience, this was devastating. Obviously Jews, Christians and Muslims all have a historical connection to parts of Israel and the West Bank, but to try to expunge the Jewish connection as if they had no claim was provocative and self-defeating." (ibid)

Witches Brew 4

Hard right Catholic Liberal MLC, Marie Ficarra, once described by former premier Bob Carr as "like Bronwyn Bishop without the delicacy," was all hyperbole in her most interesting 'contribution' to September 15's NSW Legislative Council 'debate' on BDS. For Ficarra BDS is just plain...

"Evil will continue to flourish if good men and women do and say nothing. We are elected to speak out on behalf of the many silent citizens who find this thing abominable."

"I make a prediction now that BDS will become one of the most evil acronyms we know. It is already tainted with evil."

In addition to her Savonarola routine, Ficarra demonstrated an interesting approach to research:

First, grab a quote (from an Israeli, of course) to butress your case (such as it is), but don't bother with quotation marks or acknowledging your source. And here it is, lifted word-for-word from Meretz MK slams boycotts, binational state as 'recipe for civil war', engageonline.wordpress.com, 18/10/10:

"A member of the Israeli Knesset, Nitzan Horowitz, spoke in England about his opposition to the boycott of Israeli citizens and institutions and slammed the idea of a single bilateral nation as a recipe for failure and civil war. He stated: 'I am against boycotts. I don't think this is a positive way to act'."

Second, ignore the following contrary evidence for Horowitz's stance on boycotts in general and BDS in particular:

1) "In 2009, [Horowitz] announced that he would boycott all the events in Pope Benedict XVI's visit to Israel, saying that in his opinion, the pope bears a message of 'rigidness, religious extremism and imperviousness'." (Wikipedia: Nitzan Horowitz)

2) "The Knesset - Israel's parliament - passed into law a bill allowing citizens to seek civil damages against individuals or organizations that campaign for economic, cultural, or academic boycotts against Israel or the settlements. Passage of the bill marks a major setback for the boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) movement, which seeks to pressure Israel to recognize Palestinian sovereignty and end the occupation of the West Bank and Gaza. Nitzan Horowitz, a member of the Knesset from the Meretz party, blasted the law. 'We are dealing with a legislation that is an embarrassment to Israeli democracy and makes people around the world wonder if there is actually democracy here', he said." (Israel passes controversial anti-boycott bill amidst heated debate in Knesset, thinkprogress.org, 11/7/11)

Will the real Nitzan Horowitz please stand up?

A little more tripe about citizens being "bombarded, intimidated or prevented from entering" Max Brenner outlets, a salute to the master(s) of ceremonies in the gallery - "I also acknowledge Yair Miller and Vic Alhadeff from the Jewish Board of Deputies for their strong contribution to democracy and justice" - and the ritual back-to-the-thirties reference - "We must never forget the evils of Nazism or bend to anti-Semitic racism. We must take every opportunity to speak out against it and to act against it" - and Ficarra was done.

A noble sentiment indeed, that last one. But then just how seriously can you take someone who wouldn't know a racist mob in full cry if it was strutting its stuff on her very doorstep?:

"We do not want our fellow citizens to feel so disempowered, alienated and frustrated that they need to take action en masse, as some did on the streets of my home suburb of Cronulla in 2005 - in fact, outside my front balcony on North Cronulla Beach." (Inaugural Speech LC, 5/6/07)

Sunday, October 2, 2011

SFA, Slavoj!

Fashionable Slovenian philosopher Slavoj Zizek, in Sydney for the Festival of Dangerous Ideas, outs himself in yesterday's Sydney Morning Herald as a complete goose:

"The cover story of Time magazine on June 5, 2006, was 'The World's Deadliest War' - a detailed documentation on how about 4 million people died in Congo as the result of political violence over the previous decade. None of the usual humanitarian uproar followed, just a couple of readers' letters - as if a filtering mechanism blocked this news from achieving its full impact. To put it cynically, Time picked the wrong victim in the struggle for hegemony in suffering: it should have stuck to the list of usual suspects: Muslim women and their plight, the oppression in Tibet. Congo today has effectively re-emerged as a Conradian 'heart of darkness' - no one dares to confront it head-on. The death of a West Bank Palestinian child, or an Israeli or an American, is worth thousands of times more to the media than the death of a nameless Congolese." (Drilling into hearts of darkness: The West's thirst for doing business allows it to remain oblivious to the violence in its economic & political systems, Slavoj Zizek, Sydney Morning Herald, 1/10/11)

I'm sorry, but WTF is the usual humanitarian uproar (hereinafter UHU)? When the ABC's Four Corners screened the harrowing BBC documentary The Killing Fields of Sri Lanka in July, there was no UHU. (See my posts A Deafening Silence (6/7/11) & ADS 2 (8/7/11)). Nor has ABC TV screened a single doco on the Killing Fields of Gaza to elicit one iota of Zizek's imagined UHU.

As if a filtering mechanism...? Zizek here seems to have no idea of - or shows no interest in - the corporate media's actual self-censorship filter that comes into play whenever the subject of Israeli colonisation and apartheid arises. And what can one say of the filtering mechanism that landed him one whole page of Saturday's Herald but denied any platform on the opinion page for Israeli-born critic of Israel Miko Peled, who was in this country mere days ago? Now there's a Dangerous Idea I can't see the Herald ever promoting for public discussion.

And what of Zizek's struggle for hegemony in suffering? What struggle? I always thought that'd been won hands down by the Holocaust Industry years ago. Is not Zizek aware of this? Apparently not, given that the usual suspects which roll off his tongue are Muslim women and Tibetans.

But it's the following sentence - The death of a West Bank Palestinian child, or an Israeli or an American, is worth thousands of times more to the media than the death of a nameless Congolese - that really gets on my goat.

Firstly, there's the placing of the 1,471* Palestinian child victims of the Middle East conflict (since 9/00) on the same level as the 125 Israeli child victims as though there's some balance of suffering at work here.

Secondly, I defy Zizek to name one murdered Palestinian West Bank child that's ever excited the corporate media's attention.

By way of testing his breezy suggestion that Palestinian AND Israeli child deaths suck up an equal (not to mention disproportionate) amount of ms media oxygen, let's check out the latest Palestinian and Israeli child deaths and see which has received the kind of media attention Zizek's alleging.

The last death of an Israeli child, according to the website Remember These Children, was that of 16-year old Daniel Viflic, killed on a school bus in southern Israel on 7 April when it was hit by an anti-tank missile fired from the Gaza Strip.

Apart from the prominence given to Daniel's death in the Israeli media and the proliferation of mentions on Zionist websites generally, news of his death not only found its way into the BBC news (Israeli boy Daniel Viflic dies after rocket hits bus, bbc.co.uk) and the New York Times (Missile from Gaza hits school bus, Isabel Kershner, 7/4/11), but even resulted in the British foreign secretary, William Hague, issuing the following statement:

"I learned with sorrow of the death today of Daniel Viflic, who had been gravely wounded in the attack by Hamas on an Israeli school bus on 7 April. Daniel was just 16. The tragedy of his death is brought home all the more in that it occurs on the eve of Passover, normally a time of celebration for Jewish families all over the world. I would like to extend my deepest sympathies to Daniel's family. And I reiterate my utter abhorrence of the cowardly attack which cost him his life, and my call for an end to all such attacks on innocent civilians."

But what of 13-year old Haitham Ahmad Mustafa Maruf of Beit Lahiya, Gaza, who died in Gaza's Shifa Hospital of wounds sustained from an IDF drone attack while working on his family farm on August 21?

SFA, Slavoj!

[* See rememberthesechildren.org]