Drop everything and read this fascinating account of the Galilee village of Buqei'a in the 1920s:
"Turning aside, the cavalcade rode into the village [of Bukeia], one of the oldest in Palestine, and extremely interesting as it holds the most ancient community of Jews in the Holy Land. They have been there for many centuries; according to their own story they are the descendants of the Jews who lived there before the Dispersion, it is quite probable they are, and that they escaped both Roman and Arab exterminators. It is in a most inaccessible spot in the mountains, and may well have been overlooked, even by those professed and bitter anti-Semites, the Crusaders. In this village, small as it is there are 3 distinct communities, Christian, Jew and Moslem, they live, and always have done, in the most perfect amity and accord. The Jewish community claims that both the Christians and Moslems living amongst them are of Hebrew blood, that they represent the people who apostatized many centuries ago. It is certain that the good offices of both these communities have time and again, according to the local tradition, saved the Jews of the village from persecution and even martyrdom, under the many conquerors these villages have known since Flavius Josephus surrendered in the well of Jotapata, and the last trace of independent Israelitish rule disappeared. A small Druze community, also, inhabits the outskirts of the place and lives on the most cordial relationship with the other peoples." (Galilee Galloper, Douglas V. Duff, 1935, pp 92-93)
The "cavalcade" referred to by Duff was a contingent of Palestine police led by a Briton known to the Palestinians of western Galilee as 'Abu George'. They had ridden into Buqei'a to investigate the murder of a Christian woman.
Writes Duff tellingly:
"Riding into the village at the head of his men, Abu George had expected to find the place seething with excitement, and to find the Christians demanding vengeance at his hands from one of the other sects, a situation which would have arisen in any other part of Palestine. Here the elders of the four communities had met together and were solemnly discussing the affair."
(The murderer, as it happens, turned out to be the woman's husband.)
Known also as Peki'in (or Peqi'in) in Hebrew, Buqei'a is now an almost exclusively Druze town.
Almost: "The only Jewish resident to remain in the village is Margalit Zinati, whose family has lived in Peki'in for centuries." (Last Jewish family leaves Peki'in, Goel Beno, ynetnews.com, 3/12/07)
In Buqei'a we have the intriguing case of a Palestinian Arab village, in which Arab Muslims, Arab Christians, Arab Jews and Arab Druze had lived harmoniously together for centuries, but which is now almost exclusively Druze.
So what happened to destroy this tiny model of sectarian co-existence?
In a word, Zionism.
In the 1920s and 30s, the British flooded Palestine with European Zionist colons, the latter hell-bent on transforming a multi-sectarian land into a Jewish majority state. The native Arabs, as natives have done throughout the history of European colonialism, resisted this foreign invasion, a resistance that today's Zionists and their dupes still seem to find utterly surprising and totally unreasonable for reasons that escape me.
Unfortunately for Palestine's Arab Jews, however, the Zionist colons' fraudulent conflation of Zionism with Judaism led to them being tarred with the Zionist brush. And so, when indigenous Arab resistance to the Zionists and their British backers peaked, in 1929, and again from 1936-1939, Arab Jews also felt the heat. The result in Buqei'a? In 1936, at the start of the first great Palestinian uprising, most of its Arab Jews left, never to return.
Those in search of an indigenous Palestinian model of ethno-religious harmony, as inspiration for a future non-sectarian, non-Zionist state between 'the river and the sea', need look no further than the little Palestinian village of Buqei'a as it was in the 1920s.
Showing posts with label Douglas V. Duff. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Douglas V. Duff. Show all posts
Friday, August 9, 2013
Thursday, November 8, 2012
Curse You!
"It may fail. I do not deny that this is an adventure. Are we never to have adventures? Are we never to try new experiments?" Lord Balfour, House of Lords, 21 June, 1922
Further to the subject of Little Britain and the Palestinians, I note the following, staggering report:
"Every schoolboy used to know that at the height of the empire, almost a quarter of the atlas was coloured pink, showing the extent of British rule. But that oft-recited fact dramatically understates the remarkable global reach achieved by this country. A new study has found that at various times the British have invaded almost 90% of the countries around the globe. The analysis of the histories of the almost 200 countries in the world found only 22 which have never experienced an invasion by the British... The analysis is contained in a new book, All the Countries We've Ever Invaded: And the Few We Never Got Round To. Stuart Laycock, the author, has worked his way around the globe, through each country alphabetically, researching its history to establish whether, at any point, they have experienced an incursion by Britain. Only a comparatively small proportion of the total in Mr Laycock's list of invaded states actually formed an official part of the empire. The remainder have been included because the British were found to have achieved some sort of military presence in the territory - however transitory - either through force, the threat of force, negotiation or payment. Incursions by British pirates, privateers or armed explorers have also been included, provided they were operating with the approval of their government." (British have invaded nine out of ten countries - so look out Luxembourg, Jasper Copping, telegraph.co.uk, 4/11/12)
Stuart Laycock is quoted as saying: "The book is not intended as any kind of moral judgment on our history or on our empire. It is meant as a light-hearted bit of fun." While I appreciate his efforts in exposing the extent of Britain's global depredations over the centuries, BOLLOCKS! is about all I can muster in response to his apologetic suggestion that "moral judgment" should somehow take a back seat to the "fun" of the exercise.
Certainly, for a people such as the Palestinians, who have lost everything as a result of Britain not only invading but literally giving their country away to certain feral 'friends and acquaintances', memories of British rule evoke only one kind of verbal response - the curse.
The following 3 examples are recorded by former Palestine policeman and author Douglas V. Duff. The first two come from the opening year of the great Palestinian revolt of 1936-1939 which the British put down with the utmost savagery. The third comes from the early fifties, followed the Nakba of 1948:
1)
"At the Pillar of the Five Holes [in the Church of the Nativity]... I saw a tall woman in her steeple-headdress, standing taut and dry-eyed, her hands clenched rigidly at her sides. I knew her well, she was a woman about 50, who had been housekeeper to some friends of mine in Bethlehem.
"'Subbikh b'il Khair ya Um Boutros.' ('May thy morning be blessed, O Mother of Peter'), I said.
"Slowly she turned and looked at me. Without showing surprise at seeing me, she spoke in a low voice and with a bitter intensity of venom.
"'May thy mornings, and that of all thy accursed countrymen and women, be black and damned! she answered, never raising her voice. 'May your nation perish and God forget you! May He make you prey to your enemies! May he blast the womb of every woman in your land! Have you not heard? Peter, my only son, is dead. Dead! Killed by the bullets of your assassin British police. Speak not to me, Duff Effendi, I wish to have no speech with any man of the English.' Deliberately she turned away from me and resumed her stony, wrapt contemplation of the dimly-seen, far-off altar.
"Awed and bitterly sorry, I turned away. I had known Peter, her son. Often had I given him a few piastres, or jockeyed him into a good position to see the colourful pageants when the Patriarchs arrived at Christmas-tide in his town. His mother, one of the finest type of native Christian ladies, had been one of the most loyal supporters that Britain possessed. She had been an admirer of our regime, and saw in our occupation of the Holy Land the answer to centuries of despairing prayer, the reward of countless martyrdoms and humiliations of her people. And now she lived to curse us." (Palestine Picture, 1936, pp 175-176)
2)
"Two or three miles on and we approached Bireh. Screams and yells, and the dreadful keening note of the Arab women mourning their dead, came from one of the houses, and as we stopped at a soldier-manned barrier a young woman came rushing towards us, her dress torn down the front, her breasts exposed, ashes rubbed on to her face and into her hair, a dreadful look of delirium in her eyes.
"'English murderers, English dogs!' she screamed. 'May you and all your nation perish. May you lie beneath the heel of a tyrant. May your women and children be bereaved by foreign bullies even as I am bereaved. May the blood of Isa, my brother, be visited upon all of you, may his spirit haunt your death-beds. What harm has my family ever done to you that he should be killed like a sheep? Why should he be murdered, he for whom we lived in poverty that he might go to the best schools? Have we denied ourselves all these years that he should be butchered by your shameless ruffians?' The maiden collapsed moaning upon the ground.
"'Poor thing,' said a corporal, dispassionately. 'Nice looking piece, too, if she were washed and dressed up a bit. What an 'ell of a fuss these Eastern people do make over things, screaming and yelling all over the place, and rubbing muck on themselves.'
"'Who is she, corporal?' I asked.
"'I'm 'anged if I know,' he replied. 'Must be some relation of that young blighter that we bumped off yesterday evening when 'e refused to 'alt and ran away from our patrol-lorry.' He paused, 'Ad a revolver in 'is pocket, too, curse 'im.'
"As elsewhere in the world, it is the woman who, in the long run, does the paying." (ibid, pp 260-261)
3)
"The three decades during which the flag of Britain rustled in the hot suns of Palestinian summer and the cold blasts of a Jerusalem winter are gone, and with them has fled much of our honour. The saddest commentary on what we did, or, even more exactly, on what we failed to do, was spoken by an Arab refugee when I was recently in the Middle East, making my sixth Outganging to the land of Outremer. I had known this Muslim gentleman when he was the head of a wealthy, respectable, honourable family living on his own land in the hills of Galilee.
"'Why did you Franks ever come to our country to ruin us and to leave us to die in exile?' he asked. 'Why could you not have left us to the Turks? Under the Sultan we had, at least, security to live on our own land, under our own religion and without fear of infidel supplanters. Why did you lie to us, buoy us with false hopes, make yourselves foesworn? May God punish your England in the same fashion as He has permitted you of Britain to be the instruments to undo my people! May you, too, know exile, the breaking up of families, hunger, destitution, violent death, and see your homes in the grasp of a trespasser, your woman and children dead at your feet before you die yourselves!'" (Bailing With a Teaspoon, 1953, p 218)
Further to the subject of Little Britain and the Palestinians, I note the following, staggering report:
"Every schoolboy used to know that at the height of the empire, almost a quarter of the atlas was coloured pink, showing the extent of British rule. But that oft-recited fact dramatically understates the remarkable global reach achieved by this country. A new study has found that at various times the British have invaded almost 90% of the countries around the globe. The analysis of the histories of the almost 200 countries in the world found only 22 which have never experienced an invasion by the British... The analysis is contained in a new book, All the Countries We've Ever Invaded: And the Few We Never Got Round To. Stuart Laycock, the author, has worked his way around the globe, through each country alphabetically, researching its history to establish whether, at any point, they have experienced an incursion by Britain. Only a comparatively small proportion of the total in Mr Laycock's list of invaded states actually formed an official part of the empire. The remainder have been included because the British were found to have achieved some sort of military presence in the territory - however transitory - either through force, the threat of force, negotiation or payment. Incursions by British pirates, privateers or armed explorers have also been included, provided they were operating with the approval of their government." (British have invaded nine out of ten countries - so look out Luxembourg, Jasper Copping, telegraph.co.uk, 4/11/12)
Stuart Laycock is quoted as saying: "The book is not intended as any kind of moral judgment on our history or on our empire. It is meant as a light-hearted bit of fun." While I appreciate his efforts in exposing the extent of Britain's global depredations over the centuries, BOLLOCKS! is about all I can muster in response to his apologetic suggestion that "moral judgment" should somehow take a back seat to the "fun" of the exercise.
Certainly, for a people such as the Palestinians, who have lost everything as a result of Britain not only invading but literally giving their country away to certain feral 'friends and acquaintances', memories of British rule evoke only one kind of verbal response - the curse.
The following 3 examples are recorded by former Palestine policeman and author Douglas V. Duff. The first two come from the opening year of the great Palestinian revolt of 1936-1939 which the British put down with the utmost savagery. The third comes from the early fifties, followed the Nakba of 1948:
1)
"At the Pillar of the Five Holes [in the Church of the Nativity]... I saw a tall woman in her steeple-headdress, standing taut and dry-eyed, her hands clenched rigidly at her sides. I knew her well, she was a woman about 50, who had been housekeeper to some friends of mine in Bethlehem.
"'Subbikh b'il Khair ya Um Boutros.' ('May thy morning be blessed, O Mother of Peter'), I said.
"Slowly she turned and looked at me. Without showing surprise at seeing me, she spoke in a low voice and with a bitter intensity of venom.
"'May thy mornings, and that of all thy accursed countrymen and women, be black and damned! she answered, never raising her voice. 'May your nation perish and God forget you! May He make you prey to your enemies! May he blast the womb of every woman in your land! Have you not heard? Peter, my only son, is dead. Dead! Killed by the bullets of your assassin British police. Speak not to me, Duff Effendi, I wish to have no speech with any man of the English.' Deliberately she turned away from me and resumed her stony, wrapt contemplation of the dimly-seen, far-off altar.
"Awed and bitterly sorry, I turned away. I had known Peter, her son. Often had I given him a few piastres, or jockeyed him into a good position to see the colourful pageants when the Patriarchs arrived at Christmas-tide in his town. His mother, one of the finest type of native Christian ladies, had been one of the most loyal supporters that Britain possessed. She had been an admirer of our regime, and saw in our occupation of the Holy Land the answer to centuries of despairing prayer, the reward of countless martyrdoms and humiliations of her people. And now she lived to curse us." (Palestine Picture, 1936, pp 175-176)
2)
"Two or three miles on and we approached Bireh. Screams and yells, and the dreadful keening note of the Arab women mourning their dead, came from one of the houses, and as we stopped at a soldier-manned barrier a young woman came rushing towards us, her dress torn down the front, her breasts exposed, ashes rubbed on to her face and into her hair, a dreadful look of delirium in her eyes.
"'English murderers, English dogs!' she screamed. 'May you and all your nation perish. May you lie beneath the heel of a tyrant. May your women and children be bereaved by foreign bullies even as I am bereaved. May the blood of Isa, my brother, be visited upon all of you, may his spirit haunt your death-beds. What harm has my family ever done to you that he should be killed like a sheep? Why should he be murdered, he for whom we lived in poverty that he might go to the best schools? Have we denied ourselves all these years that he should be butchered by your shameless ruffians?' The maiden collapsed moaning upon the ground.
"'Poor thing,' said a corporal, dispassionately. 'Nice looking piece, too, if she were washed and dressed up a bit. What an 'ell of a fuss these Eastern people do make over things, screaming and yelling all over the place, and rubbing muck on themselves.'
"'Who is she, corporal?' I asked.
"'I'm 'anged if I know,' he replied. 'Must be some relation of that young blighter that we bumped off yesterday evening when 'e refused to 'alt and ran away from our patrol-lorry.' He paused, 'Ad a revolver in 'is pocket, too, curse 'im.'
"As elsewhere in the world, it is the woman who, in the long run, does the paying." (ibid, pp 260-261)
3)
"The three decades during which the flag of Britain rustled in the hot suns of Palestinian summer and the cold blasts of a Jerusalem winter are gone, and with them has fled much of our honour. The saddest commentary on what we did, or, even more exactly, on what we failed to do, was spoken by an Arab refugee when I was recently in the Middle East, making my sixth Outganging to the land of Outremer. I had known this Muslim gentleman when he was the head of a wealthy, respectable, honourable family living on his own land in the hills of Galilee.
"'Why did you Franks ever come to our country to ruin us and to leave us to die in exile?' he asked. 'Why could you not have left us to the Turks? Under the Sultan we had, at least, security to live on our own land, under our own religion and without fear of infidel supplanters. Why did you lie to us, buoy us with false hopes, make yourselves foesworn? May God punish your England in the same fashion as He has permitted you of Britain to be the instruments to undo my people! May you, too, know exile, the breaking up of families, hunger, destitution, violent death, and see your homes in the grasp of a trespasser, your woman and children dead at your feet before you die yourselves!'" (Bailing With a Teaspoon, 1953, p 218)
Labels:
Balfour Declaration,
British Palestine,
colonialism,
Douglas V. Duff,
UK
Wednesday, October 24, 2012
The Very Shadow of a Shadow of a Shade
Next time you hear Julia Gillard or any other Western politician droning on about a two-state solution to the Palestine problem, it's worth casting your mind back to the very first two-state proposal for Palestine, that of Britain's 1937 Peel Commission, which proposed dividing the restive territory, 25 - 75%, into a Jewish and an Arab state. (It was of course vehemently rejected by the Palestinian Arab leadership - after all it was their country - and more cautiously by the Zionist leadership, who have only ever paid lip service to the idea of lines on a map.)
The stark fact these days, taking the much trumpeted two-state solution seriously for the moment, is that the Palestinians can expect far less than what the Zionist immigrants of the 1920s and 30s were offered by the Peel partition plan. The question arises, therefore, as to why any self-respecting Palestinian today should take the notion of a Palestinian micro-state seriously.
The following description of what a Jewish micro-state in Palestine may have looked like in 1937, had it ever come into being, was recorded by former Palestine policeman and author Douglas V Duff in his 1938 travel memoir, Poor Knight's Saddle. On a visit there in 1937, he asked the Deputy High Priest of the Samaritans in Nablus the following question:
"'Eminence... will you be good enough to say what you think of this scheme of dividing Palestine between Briton, Jew and Arab.'"
The following conversation (with Duff referring to himself as "the Scribe") ensued:
"'Do you wish for my opinion as a priest, or as a man who knows Palestine,' he demanded with a twinkle in his deep-set eyes. 'If you want me to speak as a priest, I must refuse, for my people must be considered when we speak as the mouthpiece of Israel.'
"Then as an intelligent man who knows all that there is to be known of this vexed matter,' said the Scribe.
"Well, speaking as an ordinary man, voicing my own personal opinion, I doubt whether this scheme will be very attractive to the Zionist Jews. Why should it? They are being asked to give up the very substantial things which they have won during the past few years, and to exchange for them the very shadow of a shade.
"'This State that is offered them will be sovereign only in name. It will have no rights except on paper. The British will always be there, behind the scenes, with Treaty rights to use their roads, their railways, and the air above their fields. They will have the right to maintain garrisons within the boundaries of the Jewish State. There will be islands of British land in the very middle of the State, at Nazareth and along the waters of the Sea of Galilee. The State will be cut across by the Jaffa-Jerusalem corridor. They are not to have Jerusalem, not even the New City which is entirely theirs, and, to add to the difficulties,, there is to be a free, sovereign and independent Arab City, Jaffa, right on the doorstep of Tel Aviv, their biggest city. I say, honestly, that the Zionists will be mad if they agree to accept so foolish a suggestion. They are not mad, Effendi, they are very capable, honest men, firm in their belief that they are merely the trustees for the generation that will come after them. No, this crazy proposal of your legislators will never do, it cannot be accepted." (pp 117-118)
Uncannily familiar, isn't it?
Now if, as His Eminence averred, the Zionists would have been crazy to accept such a crazy proposal, how much crazier would Mahmoud Abbas's mob be to accept the even crazier proposal - the very shadow of a shadow of a shade if you will - now being dangled before them?
Roll on the one-state solution.
The stark fact these days, taking the much trumpeted two-state solution seriously for the moment, is that the Palestinians can expect far less than what the Zionist immigrants of the 1920s and 30s were offered by the Peel partition plan. The question arises, therefore, as to why any self-respecting Palestinian today should take the notion of a Palestinian micro-state seriously.
The following description of what a Jewish micro-state in Palestine may have looked like in 1937, had it ever come into being, was recorded by former Palestine policeman and author Douglas V Duff in his 1938 travel memoir, Poor Knight's Saddle. On a visit there in 1937, he asked the Deputy High Priest of the Samaritans in Nablus the following question:
"'Eminence... will you be good enough to say what you think of this scheme of dividing Palestine between Briton, Jew and Arab.'"
The following conversation (with Duff referring to himself as "the Scribe") ensued:
"'Do you wish for my opinion as a priest, or as a man who knows Palestine,' he demanded with a twinkle in his deep-set eyes. 'If you want me to speak as a priest, I must refuse, for my people must be considered when we speak as the mouthpiece of Israel.'
"Then as an intelligent man who knows all that there is to be known of this vexed matter,' said the Scribe.
"Well, speaking as an ordinary man, voicing my own personal opinion, I doubt whether this scheme will be very attractive to the Zionist Jews. Why should it? They are being asked to give up the very substantial things which they have won during the past few years, and to exchange for them the very shadow of a shade.
"'This State that is offered them will be sovereign only in name. It will have no rights except on paper. The British will always be there, behind the scenes, with Treaty rights to use their roads, their railways, and the air above their fields. They will have the right to maintain garrisons within the boundaries of the Jewish State. There will be islands of British land in the very middle of the State, at Nazareth and along the waters of the Sea of Galilee. The State will be cut across by the Jaffa-Jerusalem corridor. They are not to have Jerusalem, not even the New City which is entirely theirs, and, to add to the difficulties,, there is to be a free, sovereign and independent Arab City, Jaffa, right on the doorstep of Tel Aviv, their biggest city. I say, honestly, that the Zionists will be mad if they agree to accept so foolish a suggestion. They are not mad, Effendi, they are very capable, honest men, firm in their belief that they are merely the trustees for the generation that will come after them. No, this crazy proposal of your legislators will never do, it cannot be accepted." (pp 117-118)
Uncannily familiar, isn't it?
Now if, as His Eminence averred, the Zionists would have been crazy to accept such a crazy proposal, how much crazier would Mahmoud Abbas's mob be to accept the even crazier proposal - the very shadow of a shadow of a shade if you will - now being dangled before them?
Roll on the one-state solution.
Monday, October 15, 2012
Time to Revisit the ANZAC's Sarafand Massacre
The militarisation of the Australian mind marches on:
"Ninety-five years after the Australian Light Horse led the charge of Beersheba to claim a pivotal victory in the Middle East theatre, Australians will once again charge through the desert sands. This time they ride in peace. As commemorations gear up to mark the decisive battle, a group of 40 Australians will today start their journey to Egypt, Turkey and Israel in the footsteps of the Light Horse. Members of the Australian Light Horse Association, including descendants of WW1 veterans, will re-enact the charge on the 95th anniversary of the battle on October 31... 'We're keeping the tradition alive,' [ALHA director Barry Rodgers] said. 'One of the reasons we're doing this is to raise the profile of the Middle East campaign. It has been very much overshadowed by Gallipoli and the Western Front'. The charge on Turkish positions and on to Beersheba was regarded as a success that ultimately led to the fall of the Ottoman Empire." (Men of peace cheer charge of the Light Horse brigade, Rosanne Barrett, The Australian, 15/10/12)
One aspect of the Light Horse's sojourn in Palestine that's unlikely to be mentioned on the ALHA's 'In the Steps of the Light Horse' Tour 2012 is the post-armistace massacre of the defenceless inhabitants of the Palestinian village of Sarafand (often transliterated as Surafend) in November 1918. I've dealt with this particular war crime before (simply click on the AIF label below) but in light of the above and what is sure to follow by way of uncritical ms media attention, and as an antidote to the sickening tendency in this mercenary nation of ours to glorify all things military, it warrants revisiting.
Perhaps the most useful analytical commentary on the matter, which led to the British commander of the campaign against the Turks, General Allenby, writing off the AIF as "cold-blooded murderers," and denying them battle honours, is to be found in Passionate Histories: Myth, Memory & Indigenous Australia (2010) ed. by Peters-Little, Curthoys & Docker:
"In 1923, H.S. (Henry) Gullett, as part of Australia's official war history under the general editorship of Charles Bean, published The Australian Imperial Force in Sinai and Palestine 1914-1918, where he constructs what we might call the ur-narrative of the Surafend massacre, inscribing the strange mix, part exculpatory, part condemnatory, that provides the motifs, images and tropes for almost all succeeding purported descriptions of what occurred. Post armistace, in their camps at Tripoli and on the Philistine plain, after a very successful campaign that secured the defeat of the Ottoman forces in Sinai, Palestine and Syria, the light horsemen, Gullett writes, participated in an 'unfortunate incident' that was destined to throw a 'shadow' over their last days in Palestine. It has to be recognised, however, he adds, that they were intolerably provoked, by the indigenous inhabitants in one way, and the British high command in another; indeed, they should be regarded as victims of both. Next to the camps of the Anzac Mounted Division of Australians and New Zealanders lay 'the native village of Surafend,' which elicits the following racial typing from Gullett: 'All the Arabs of western Palestine were thieves by instinct.' The 'natives of Surafend,' he continues, 'were notorious for their petty thieving.' At night, the Australians and New Zealanders, 'sleeping soundly were a simple prey to the cunning, barefooted robbers, and night after night men lost property from their tents.' In this image, the Light Horse are 'prey' to shoeless Arabs perceived as stealthy predatory scavengers...
"Gullett's official history provides the template description of how the Surafend massacre occurred. As is often the case with massacres or scenes of violent retribution, a single individual of one's own group is injured or killed. In this case, a New Zealand soldier is shot by a Bedouin, 'the native' who had been stealing in his tent. The New Zealanders, their whole camp immediately aroused, and 'working with ominous deliberation, then trace the 'footsteps of the Arab' to Surafend. The New Zealanders throw a 'strong cordon' around the village, no Arab being allowed to leave. All day, Gullett says, the New Zealanders 'quietly organised for their work in Surafend, and then, early in the night, marched out 'many hundreds strong' and surrounded the village. In his narrative, Gullett stresses that only male Bedouin were harmed. When they entered the village, the 'New Zealanders grimly passed out all the women and children,' and then, 'armed chiefly with heavy sticks, fell upon the men and at the same time fired the houses.' Many Arabs, Gullett tells us, were killed and few escaped injury; the village was demolished and set on fire, and the flames from the 'wretched houses lit up the countryside.' The Anzacs next 'raided and burned the neighbouring nomad camp,' and then went 'quietly back to their lines.'
"Gullett concedes that what happened 'cannot be justified,' and affirms that Surafend 'should not be forgotten.' Nonetheless, he insists, 'in fairness to the New Zealanders and to the Australians who gave them hearty support,' we have to consider that the soldiers 'were the pioneers and the leaders in a long campaign.' They had just lost a 'veteran comrade,' at the hands of a race they despised'; consequently, he feels, they became 'angry and bitter beyond sound reasoning.'" (pp 56-57)
Just for the record, here are two 2 other references to the Sarafand massacre not available on the internet. The first, by our Palestine policeman Douglas V. Duff (click on the label below), reprises (derives from?) Gullett's colonial portrayal of Palestinian Arabs as instinctual thieves. Duff, you'll notice, 'improves' on Gullett in several respects.
"A mile away [from Ramleh] is the village of Sarafand, a place that suffered severely from the Australians during the military occupation. A set of thieving, murderous, cowardly curs are these men of Sarafand; sand-rats who preyed upon the soldiers, and ended by treacherously murdering several. The Australians, maddened by the deaths of their comrades, surrounded the village, sacked it, and killed some of the worst characters who lived there - a lesson that Sarafand has never forgotten. They are no longer active criminals, but any brigand, highway robber, or fugitive from justice, is assured of a welcome from them, always supposing that the Government has not offered a price for his capture, in which case he is certain of betrayal." (Palestine Picture, 1936, p 192)
Much closer to the time comes this brief, teasing reference from the Regimental Medical Officer to the 39th Royal Fusiliers, the 2nd Judean Battalion, Redcliffe Salaman. Salaman is writing to his wife from Ludd (Lydda/Lod) Palestine on 18 December, 1918:
"When I get home I will tell you a rather terrible tale concerning the way that Australians avenged a murder of one of their men here. It was an ordered lynch law - a mixture of chivalry and sternest justice, absolutely spontaneous..." (Palestine Reclaimed, 1920, pp 143-144)
"Ninety-five years after the Australian Light Horse led the charge of Beersheba to claim a pivotal victory in the Middle East theatre, Australians will once again charge through the desert sands. This time they ride in peace. As commemorations gear up to mark the decisive battle, a group of 40 Australians will today start their journey to Egypt, Turkey and Israel in the footsteps of the Light Horse. Members of the Australian Light Horse Association, including descendants of WW1 veterans, will re-enact the charge on the 95th anniversary of the battle on October 31... 'We're keeping the tradition alive,' [ALHA director Barry Rodgers] said. 'One of the reasons we're doing this is to raise the profile of the Middle East campaign. It has been very much overshadowed by Gallipoli and the Western Front'. The charge on Turkish positions and on to Beersheba was regarded as a success that ultimately led to the fall of the Ottoman Empire." (Men of peace cheer charge of the Light Horse brigade, Rosanne Barrett, The Australian, 15/10/12)
One aspect of the Light Horse's sojourn in Palestine that's unlikely to be mentioned on the ALHA's 'In the Steps of the Light Horse' Tour 2012 is the post-armistace massacre of the defenceless inhabitants of the Palestinian village of Sarafand (often transliterated as Surafend) in November 1918. I've dealt with this particular war crime before (simply click on the AIF label below) but in light of the above and what is sure to follow by way of uncritical ms media attention, and as an antidote to the sickening tendency in this mercenary nation of ours to glorify all things military, it warrants revisiting.
Perhaps the most useful analytical commentary on the matter, which led to the British commander of the campaign against the Turks, General Allenby, writing off the AIF as "cold-blooded murderers," and denying them battle honours, is to be found in Passionate Histories: Myth, Memory & Indigenous Australia (2010) ed. by Peters-Little, Curthoys & Docker:
"In 1923, H.S. (Henry) Gullett, as part of Australia's official war history under the general editorship of Charles Bean, published The Australian Imperial Force in Sinai and Palestine 1914-1918, where he constructs what we might call the ur-narrative of the Surafend massacre, inscribing the strange mix, part exculpatory, part condemnatory, that provides the motifs, images and tropes for almost all succeeding purported descriptions of what occurred. Post armistace, in their camps at Tripoli and on the Philistine plain, after a very successful campaign that secured the defeat of the Ottoman forces in Sinai, Palestine and Syria, the light horsemen, Gullett writes, participated in an 'unfortunate incident' that was destined to throw a 'shadow' over their last days in Palestine. It has to be recognised, however, he adds, that they were intolerably provoked, by the indigenous inhabitants in one way, and the British high command in another; indeed, they should be regarded as victims of both. Next to the camps of the Anzac Mounted Division of Australians and New Zealanders lay 'the native village of Surafend,' which elicits the following racial typing from Gullett: 'All the Arabs of western Palestine were thieves by instinct.' The 'natives of Surafend,' he continues, 'were notorious for their petty thieving.' At night, the Australians and New Zealanders, 'sleeping soundly were a simple prey to the cunning, barefooted robbers, and night after night men lost property from their tents.' In this image, the Light Horse are 'prey' to shoeless Arabs perceived as stealthy predatory scavengers...
"Gullett's official history provides the template description of how the Surafend massacre occurred. As is often the case with massacres or scenes of violent retribution, a single individual of one's own group is injured or killed. In this case, a New Zealand soldier is shot by a Bedouin, 'the native' who had been stealing in his tent. The New Zealanders, their whole camp immediately aroused, and 'working with ominous deliberation, then trace the 'footsteps of the Arab' to Surafend. The New Zealanders throw a 'strong cordon' around the village, no Arab being allowed to leave. All day, Gullett says, the New Zealanders 'quietly organised for their work in Surafend, and then, early in the night, marched out 'many hundreds strong' and surrounded the village. In his narrative, Gullett stresses that only male Bedouin were harmed. When they entered the village, the 'New Zealanders grimly passed out all the women and children,' and then, 'armed chiefly with heavy sticks, fell upon the men and at the same time fired the houses.' Many Arabs, Gullett tells us, were killed and few escaped injury; the village was demolished and set on fire, and the flames from the 'wretched houses lit up the countryside.' The Anzacs next 'raided and burned the neighbouring nomad camp,' and then went 'quietly back to their lines.'
"Gullett concedes that what happened 'cannot be justified,' and affirms that Surafend 'should not be forgotten.' Nonetheless, he insists, 'in fairness to the New Zealanders and to the Australians who gave them hearty support,' we have to consider that the soldiers 'were the pioneers and the leaders in a long campaign.' They had just lost a 'veteran comrade,' at the hands of a race they despised'; consequently, he feels, they became 'angry and bitter beyond sound reasoning.'" (pp 56-57)
Just for the record, here are two 2 other references to the Sarafand massacre not available on the internet. The first, by our Palestine policeman Douglas V. Duff (click on the label below), reprises (derives from?) Gullett's colonial portrayal of Palestinian Arabs as instinctual thieves. Duff, you'll notice, 'improves' on Gullett in several respects.
"A mile away [from Ramleh] is the village of Sarafand, a place that suffered severely from the Australians during the military occupation. A set of thieving, murderous, cowardly curs are these men of Sarafand; sand-rats who preyed upon the soldiers, and ended by treacherously murdering several. The Australians, maddened by the deaths of their comrades, surrounded the village, sacked it, and killed some of the worst characters who lived there - a lesson that Sarafand has never forgotten. They are no longer active criminals, but any brigand, highway robber, or fugitive from justice, is assured of a welcome from them, always supposing that the Government has not offered a price for his capture, in which case he is certain of betrayal." (Palestine Picture, 1936, p 192)
Much closer to the time comes this brief, teasing reference from the Regimental Medical Officer to the 39th Royal Fusiliers, the 2nd Judean Battalion, Redcliffe Salaman. Salaman is writing to his wife from Ludd (Lydda/Lod) Palestine on 18 December, 1918:
"When I get home I will tell you a rather terrible tale concerning the way that Australians avenged a murder of one of their men here. It was an ordered lynch law - a mixture of chivalry and sternest justice, absolutely spontaneous..." (Palestine Reclaimed, 1920, pp 143-144)
Wednesday, October 10, 2012
Truganini in Jerusalem
"They consider every injury they can inflict upon white men as an act of duty and patriotic, and however they may dread the punishment which our laws inflict upon them, they consider the sufferers under these punishments as martyrs of their country... having ideas of their natural rights which would astonish most of our European statesmen." (Gilbert Robinson, 1828, quoted in Tasmanian Aborigines: A History Since 1803, Lyndall Ryan, 2012)
It's 1936, Year One of the Palestine Revolt (1936-1939). Author and former Palestine policeman, Douglas Duff, on a visit to the country, is listening to the speech of a Palestinian agitator in a Jerusalem bazaar when it suddenly takes a most unexpected turn:
"Jerusalem, within the walls, seemed empty and dead; yet it needed very little imagination or knowledge of the East to feel the pulsing, ageless, ancient life that was beating malevolently behind those shuttered walls. At the large coffee-house on the left-hand side, in front of the dark arches that cover the junction of the Spice Bazaar, the Goldsmith's Bazaar and the entry to the Jewish Quarter, I paused for a moment amongst a crowd of elderly Arab merchants who were listening to a young man haranguing the smoking, coffee-drinking crowd in the restaurant. I was curious to hear what latest twist the agitator propaganda was taking, and listened with every nerve in my mind.
"'And so I tell you, Brothers in the Faith,' shouted the young man, 'that this is our last chance to save the blood of the Arab from becoming nothing but a memory in this land of our fathers. If you do not wish to see the sons of Islam barred from the Great Sanctuary, if you wish to have your sons and your sons' sons to have the right of enjoying this land of ours, you must stand loyally by your leaders. If we do not bring the Ingliz to their senses - and we can only do so by frightening them - then we are lost.'
"He paused for a moment. Very ordinary stuff, this. I was not greatly impressed, but his next few sentences startled me, for I had had no idea that the forces working against England were so well trained.
"'You all know the accursed Balfour Declaration by heart?'
"A savage growling arose from the seated mob, and curses against Jew and Briton were shouted. The young man, in his blue serge suit and scarlet tarbush, waited for it to die down with a smile upon his face, and then went on.
"The Ingliz tell us that the rights of the Arabs will be safeguarded. Let me show you what liars they are. Let me tell you of one colony of which they have possession. Listen with all your ears to what happened, in a few short years, to the native population of that country. Remember that we, the sons of the Arab - who were a great nation when the Ingliz were lower than the Blacks of Africa are to-day - are nothing but 'natives' to these proud white men. What they have done to one 'native' race, they will be only too willing to do to another.'
"By now you could have heard a pin drop in the crowded coffee-house. With strained attention the Arabs, most of them of the village and Bedouin type - for there were few townsmen among them - crouched forward to hear what the young Effendi had to say.
"'What I am going to tell you is true; do not think that my father's son lies. When you go forth to your own villages you must bear the tale I am about to tell you as a warning for all to heed, if they would live and possess the land of our fathers.'
"I began to wonder to which particular colony the young man was going to refer, what unparalleled lie he was going to utter. Unfortunately he had ferreted out the truth.
"'To the south of Australia,' he said, 'the land which sent all those soldiers to Palestine during the last War, there is a large island called Tasmania, nearly three times greater in area than this Holy Land. One hundred and thirty years ago it had a large and happy native population, who had lived for untold ages secure in their own country. I will speak in terms of the Western years, the time of the Franks, for it is in their style that the chronicle is written. This year, as you all know, is 1936, according to their counting. Then, in 1804, the Tasmanians - 'natives' in the eyes of the Ingliz - were a happy and contented people. What happened to them? I will tell you.'
"He paused, whilst the crowd held its breath. Then, in accents of awe, mingled with deadly hatred, he went on:
"'In the year 1869 the last Tasmanian died; in 1876 the last of the Tasmanian women died in London, and the 'natives' of Tasmania were completely extinguished! A nation, a race, a whole people had been stamped out completely in seventy-two years! How was it done? By bullets and bayonets and unjust laws; by English hatred and greed. That is how it was done. How many years have the Ingliz been in Palestine? Nearly twenty! Then how much longer have we left before we suffer the fate of the Tasmanians?'
"By this time he had lashed himself to a lather of fury.
"'I tell you, Brothers in the Faith, that if I were a rich man I would bring the bones of that last of the Tasmanians - the woman called Trukanini - and I would lay them beneath a great monument here in Jerusalem, for a solemn warning to all we men of Arab blood. She should be our example, our guide and our inspiration.'
"He glanced around. 'Is there one who doubts this tale? If there be, let him go to any of the learned men, ask them to consult their books, and he will find that I have spoken naught but the truth. The rights of subject peoples! I tell you that we cannot trust the Ingliz. This time we must be staunch and loyal.
"I walked quietly away, anxious to be absent from the scene ere any of the enthralled Arabs realised that one of the Ingliz was looking on; before any of them, with their passionate fanaticism alight, saw in me a heaven-sent opportunity to revenge the wrongs done long ago to the Tasmanians." (Palestine Picture, 1936, pp 65-68)
It's 1936, Year One of the Palestine Revolt (1936-1939). Author and former Palestine policeman, Douglas Duff, on a visit to the country, is listening to the speech of a Palestinian agitator in a Jerusalem bazaar when it suddenly takes a most unexpected turn:
"Jerusalem, within the walls, seemed empty and dead; yet it needed very little imagination or knowledge of the East to feel the pulsing, ageless, ancient life that was beating malevolently behind those shuttered walls. At the large coffee-house on the left-hand side, in front of the dark arches that cover the junction of the Spice Bazaar, the Goldsmith's Bazaar and the entry to the Jewish Quarter, I paused for a moment amongst a crowd of elderly Arab merchants who were listening to a young man haranguing the smoking, coffee-drinking crowd in the restaurant. I was curious to hear what latest twist the agitator propaganda was taking, and listened with every nerve in my mind.
"'And so I tell you, Brothers in the Faith,' shouted the young man, 'that this is our last chance to save the blood of the Arab from becoming nothing but a memory in this land of our fathers. If you do not wish to see the sons of Islam barred from the Great Sanctuary, if you wish to have your sons and your sons' sons to have the right of enjoying this land of ours, you must stand loyally by your leaders. If we do not bring the Ingliz to their senses - and we can only do so by frightening them - then we are lost.'
"He paused for a moment. Very ordinary stuff, this. I was not greatly impressed, but his next few sentences startled me, for I had had no idea that the forces working against England were so well trained.
"'You all know the accursed Balfour Declaration by heart?'
"A savage growling arose from the seated mob, and curses against Jew and Briton were shouted. The young man, in his blue serge suit and scarlet tarbush, waited for it to die down with a smile upon his face, and then went on.
"The Ingliz tell us that the rights of the Arabs will be safeguarded. Let me show you what liars they are. Let me tell you of one colony of which they have possession. Listen with all your ears to what happened, in a few short years, to the native population of that country. Remember that we, the sons of the Arab - who were a great nation when the Ingliz were lower than the Blacks of Africa are to-day - are nothing but 'natives' to these proud white men. What they have done to one 'native' race, they will be only too willing to do to another.'
"By now you could have heard a pin drop in the crowded coffee-house. With strained attention the Arabs, most of them of the village and Bedouin type - for there were few townsmen among them - crouched forward to hear what the young Effendi had to say.
"'What I am going to tell you is true; do not think that my father's son lies. When you go forth to your own villages you must bear the tale I am about to tell you as a warning for all to heed, if they would live and possess the land of our fathers.'
"I began to wonder to which particular colony the young man was going to refer, what unparalleled lie he was going to utter. Unfortunately he had ferreted out the truth.
"'To the south of Australia,' he said, 'the land which sent all those soldiers to Palestine during the last War, there is a large island called Tasmania, nearly three times greater in area than this Holy Land. One hundred and thirty years ago it had a large and happy native population, who had lived for untold ages secure in their own country. I will speak in terms of the Western years, the time of the Franks, for it is in their style that the chronicle is written. This year, as you all know, is 1936, according to their counting. Then, in 1804, the Tasmanians - 'natives' in the eyes of the Ingliz - were a happy and contented people. What happened to them? I will tell you.'
"He paused, whilst the crowd held its breath. Then, in accents of awe, mingled with deadly hatred, he went on:
"'In the year 1869 the last Tasmanian died; in 1876 the last of the Tasmanian women died in London, and the 'natives' of Tasmania were completely extinguished! A nation, a race, a whole people had been stamped out completely in seventy-two years! How was it done? By bullets and bayonets and unjust laws; by English hatred and greed. That is how it was done. How many years have the Ingliz been in Palestine? Nearly twenty! Then how much longer have we left before we suffer the fate of the Tasmanians?'
"By this time he had lashed himself to a lather of fury.
"'I tell you, Brothers in the Faith, that if I were a rich man I would bring the bones of that last of the Tasmanians - the woman called Trukanini - and I would lay them beneath a great monument here in Jerusalem, for a solemn warning to all we men of Arab blood. She should be our example, our guide and our inspiration.'
"He glanced around. 'Is there one who doubts this tale? If there be, let him go to any of the learned men, ask them to consult their books, and he will find that I have spoken naught but the truth. The rights of subject peoples! I tell you that we cannot trust the Ingliz. This time we must be staunch and loyal.
"I walked quietly away, anxious to be absent from the scene ere any of the enthralled Arabs realised that one of the Ingliz was looking on; before any of them, with their passionate fanaticism alight, saw in me a heaven-sent opportunity to revenge the wrongs done long ago to the Tasmanians." (Palestine Picture, 1936, pp 65-68)
Saturday, October 6, 2012
Some Things Never Change
A heart-to-heart with Greek Orthodox priest, Abuna Isa, Mar Elias monastery, Bethlehem, Palestine 1936:
"'All this talk about holding the balance between Jew and Arab makes me sick,' went on Abuna Isa. 'Does the British Government think that all the rest of the world is possessed of the brains of children? I tell you, Duff Effendi, those wretched Jews are just as much victims of your Imperial grab-alls as are the Arabs. Do you think that we do not realise why Britain is going to such pains to keep her grasp on this country? We should be blind if we did not see how necessary Palestine is for your civil aircraft as well as for your Air Force, how much you need it as an Eastern Mediterranean naval base, or the reason for protecting your new oil pipe-line from Mosul to Haifa. We are not children; we can see how vital Palestine is as a defence for the Suez Canal, now that you are scuttling out of Egypt. Why cannot you English be honest and say boldly that what you captured by the sword you intend to keep by the same means, instead of treating us to a hypocritical display of make-believe righteousness?'
"Abuna Isa's remarks were not very far from the truth. In fact, they were so near the mark that no real reply was possible to this very astute superior of a remote monastery - at least none that would sound convincing. I did try to show him that in England there was a very large body of truly altruistic opinion - people who sincerely believed that their country was carrying out a great spiritual mission in the Holy Land. He smiled sarcastically, for, good worthy man, he could make no differentiation between the nation and the nation's professional politicians. The British Government signified British opinion to him, as it does to most of the rest of the world.
"'Do not your people elect their political leaders?' he asked sarcastically. 'If their policy is so utterly against public opinion, why do they allow them to remain in office?'
"Again, it was hopeless to explain to this worthy monk the underlying reasons, the lack of real education for the British masses, who are taught only the rudiments of the three 'R's' and given no training how to think of anything abstract, or how to argue logically or constructively. Their political opinions are generally fixed by their station or trade, and their viewpoint is precisely that of their favourite penny newspaper. What they see in print is invested with the same, or more, authority and veracity as the Scriptures. The power of vested interests they do not understand, any more than they realise that they are being forcibly led by the nose wherever their political bosses may choose to go." (Palestine Picture, Douglas Duff, 1936, pp 161-162)
"'All this talk about holding the balance between Jew and Arab makes me sick,' went on Abuna Isa. 'Does the British Government think that all the rest of the world is possessed of the brains of children? I tell you, Duff Effendi, those wretched Jews are just as much victims of your Imperial grab-alls as are the Arabs. Do you think that we do not realise why Britain is going to such pains to keep her grasp on this country? We should be blind if we did not see how necessary Palestine is for your civil aircraft as well as for your Air Force, how much you need it as an Eastern Mediterranean naval base, or the reason for protecting your new oil pipe-line from Mosul to Haifa. We are not children; we can see how vital Palestine is as a defence for the Suez Canal, now that you are scuttling out of Egypt. Why cannot you English be honest and say boldly that what you captured by the sword you intend to keep by the same means, instead of treating us to a hypocritical display of make-believe righteousness?'
"Abuna Isa's remarks were not very far from the truth. In fact, they were so near the mark that no real reply was possible to this very astute superior of a remote monastery - at least none that would sound convincing. I did try to show him that in England there was a very large body of truly altruistic opinion - people who sincerely believed that their country was carrying out a great spiritual mission in the Holy Land. He smiled sarcastically, for, good worthy man, he could make no differentiation between the nation and the nation's professional politicians. The British Government signified British opinion to him, as it does to most of the rest of the world.
"'Do not your people elect their political leaders?' he asked sarcastically. 'If their policy is so utterly against public opinion, why do they allow them to remain in office?'
"Again, it was hopeless to explain to this worthy monk the underlying reasons, the lack of real education for the British masses, who are taught only the rudiments of the three 'R's' and given no training how to think of anything abstract, or how to argue logically or constructively. Their political opinions are generally fixed by their station or trade, and their viewpoint is precisely that of their favourite penny newspaper. What they see in print is invested with the same, or more, authority and veracity as the Scriptures. The power of vested interests they do not understand, any more than they realise that they are being forcibly led by the nose wherever their political bosses may choose to go." (Palestine Picture, Douglas Duff, 1936, pp 161-162)
Friday, August 3, 2012
Palestine's Patriot Dead
Remember our Dorset farmer (By George, He Gets It!, 1/7/12)?
"I was glad to get away, especially after my tour [of Acre prison] was ended by my being shown the execution chamber, and the gallows on which so many men have died. One piece of probably unwitting savagery jarred upon me. The condemned cells are cages in the vestibule to the execution-chamber. There are two of them, and if, as often happens, there is more than one execution to be carried out on a certain morning, the second or subsequent victim, must suffer the agonies of the damned - for he can see his comrade in evil fortune taken out, hear all that takes place on the farther side of the black door - and then die himself a hundred times before the bolts of his cage are shot back, and it is his turn to suffer.
"The British Inspector who took me round told me that there had been as many as 3 executions on one morning, one of them being the time when 3 men were hanged for their parts in the 1929 rebellion. 'It's not fair,' he said. 'In an English prison the governor and deputy-governor have a far easier time than Jock and I have here with these continued executions.
"'What do you mean?' I asked.
"'In England,' he replied, 'it is bad enough. Like us, a prison governor there gets to know the man who is going to be hanged. You see him every day. You know his motives and his own feelings - often a murderer is not nearly so bad a criminal as a professional thief or blackmailer, let alone a dope-dealer or a white-slaver. He's often some poor devil who has killed in a sudden fit of overmastering passion, jealousy or rage - I often feel like saying 'there but for the grace of Allah goes little me.'
"'As I say, you get to know the man, his relatives, and his own worries and family-troubles, and then you've got to kill him with your own hands, for we British officers have to act as executioners, not just stand by and watch like our opposite numbers do in England. It's a rotten job, believe me. I'm pretty tough, but I'd give anything to be really sick on an execution morning, so that I could beg off the spectacle.
"'Surely you don't get much chance to weep over the troubles of the fellows who are tried by the Military Courts?' I said.
"His face set grimly. 'No, and there'd be no tears in any case for that bunch of crooks. I want no excuse to miss their hangings, believe me.'
"'But why?' I asked. 'Aren't they quite sincere in believing that they are fighting for their rights?'
"The burly Inspector snorted. 'Don't make me sick,' he grunted. 'They're just a gang of toughs looting and killing for what they can make out of it. They're not patriots, they're criminals.'
"'I suppose that you served in the Royal Irish Constabulary, didn't you?' I asked. 'Most of the officers of the Palestine Police seem to have done so.'
"'I did,' he said, 'and it was a far better and safer job than this one.'
"'Some of the men who were hanged during the Troubles of 1919, '20 and '21, were also condemned as criminals,' I said gently. 'Kevin Barry and the rest.'
"'That was different, they were white men,' the Inspector snorted.
"'You mean that they are heroes nowadays, noble patriots, held as martyrs by their fellows, because they were white men - and, conversely, that the Arabs, whom you are hanging, are ruffianly murderers because their skins are brown?' I inquired.
"'Go to Hell!' he said, and turned upon his heel.
"I passed out of Hell, instead, by recrossing the narrow bridge, and, as I emerged on to the rampart walk, felt a dirty, greasy cloud lifting off my spirit." (Palestine Unveiled, Douglas V. Duff, 1938, pp 72-74)
"I was glad to get away, especially after my tour [of Acre prison] was ended by my being shown the execution chamber, and the gallows on which so many men have died. One piece of probably unwitting savagery jarred upon me. The condemned cells are cages in the vestibule to the execution-chamber. There are two of them, and if, as often happens, there is more than one execution to be carried out on a certain morning, the second or subsequent victim, must suffer the agonies of the damned - for he can see his comrade in evil fortune taken out, hear all that takes place on the farther side of the black door - and then die himself a hundred times before the bolts of his cage are shot back, and it is his turn to suffer.
"The British Inspector who took me round told me that there had been as many as 3 executions on one morning, one of them being the time when 3 men were hanged for their parts in the 1929 rebellion. 'It's not fair,' he said. 'In an English prison the governor and deputy-governor have a far easier time than Jock and I have here with these continued executions.
"'What do you mean?' I asked.
"'In England,' he replied, 'it is bad enough. Like us, a prison governor there gets to know the man who is going to be hanged. You see him every day. You know his motives and his own feelings - often a murderer is not nearly so bad a criminal as a professional thief or blackmailer, let alone a dope-dealer or a white-slaver. He's often some poor devil who has killed in a sudden fit of overmastering passion, jealousy or rage - I often feel like saying 'there but for the grace of Allah goes little me.'
"'As I say, you get to know the man, his relatives, and his own worries and family-troubles, and then you've got to kill him with your own hands, for we British officers have to act as executioners, not just stand by and watch like our opposite numbers do in England. It's a rotten job, believe me. I'm pretty tough, but I'd give anything to be really sick on an execution morning, so that I could beg off the spectacle.
"'Surely you don't get much chance to weep over the troubles of the fellows who are tried by the Military Courts?' I said.
"His face set grimly. 'No, and there'd be no tears in any case for that bunch of crooks. I want no excuse to miss their hangings, believe me.'
"'But why?' I asked. 'Aren't they quite sincere in believing that they are fighting for their rights?'
"The burly Inspector snorted. 'Don't make me sick,' he grunted. 'They're just a gang of toughs looting and killing for what they can make out of it. They're not patriots, they're criminals.'
"'I suppose that you served in the Royal Irish Constabulary, didn't you?' I asked. 'Most of the officers of the Palestine Police seem to have done so.'
"'I did,' he said, 'and it was a far better and safer job than this one.'
"'Some of the men who were hanged during the Troubles of 1919, '20 and '21, were also condemned as criminals,' I said gently. 'Kevin Barry and the rest.'
"'That was different, they were white men,' the Inspector snorted.
"'You mean that they are heroes nowadays, noble patriots, held as martyrs by their fellows, because they were white men - and, conversely, that the Arabs, whom you are hanging, are ruffianly murderers because their skins are brown?' I inquired.
"'Go to Hell!' he said, and turned upon his heel.
"I passed out of Hell, instead, by recrossing the narrow bridge, and, as I emerged on to the rampart walk, felt a dirty, greasy cloud lifting off my spirit." (Palestine Unveiled, Douglas V. Duff, 1938, pp 72-74)
Labels:
British Palestine,
Douglas V. Duff,
Ireland,
resistance
Sunday, July 1, 2012
By George, He Gets It!
Most people, excepting of course Zionist deadenders, 'get' Palestine. It's hardly rocket science after all. However, our politicians and their clones in the media, so many of whom seem to be slow learners here, generally struggle with the issue. But really, when all is said and done, if a chap from the Old Dart back in the 30s, a simple Dorset farmer actually, can 'get' it, surely anyone can.
What follows is part of his story as told by British writer Douglas V. Duff in his book, Palestine Unveiled (1938). The event described was a mere blip in the great Palestine Revolt of 1936-1939, when the Palestinian people rose up against the British Mandate authorities' attempt to transform their homeland, through mass immigration of European Jews and Jewish land purchases, into a National Home for something called 'the Jewish people'.* It's a tale that spans some 16 pages in the original, but I've reduced it somewhat by omitting parts of Duff's text and replacing them with brief, linking summaries. Oh, and another thing: you'll notice as you read that the British war crimes committed against the Palestinians in the 30s are today routinely committed by their Israeli apprentices:
Our farmer is visiting a monastery on Mt Carmel, overlooking the coastal city of Haifa when his conversation with one of its monks, Father Elias, is suddenly interrupted:
"Fra Elias talked away, giving me the details of the view, and I turned from one to the other, recognizing how aptly the historical narrative of the Bible fitted into it all, when there was a sudden shouting in the dip below the peak upon which the monastery stands. We stood up and looked in that direction; in a few minutes some very tired and blown British soldiers and police came toiling up the steep path to the monastery door. A man in civilian clothes, tweed shooting-jacket, breeches and khaki shirt, was holding two dogs. He, with a couple of uniformed officers, came up to us as we stepped to the door.
'Good evening, Father,' said one officer, who had a couple of metal stars on the shoulder-straps of his tunic, 'we're sorry to bother you, but I wonder if you could let us have some hot water to make tea? The men are pretty nearly all in, but with some hot tea, and a rest, they will get their second wind.'" (p 48)
Father Elias obliges and the following conversation ensues:
"'You look very tired, gentlemen,' said Fra Elias. 'We have several bedrooms. We could arrange quarters for you and your men. Will you not stay the night?'
'Sorry, Father, said the police-officer. 'I wish we could, but we've got to push on. The trail's hot, and with a bit of luck we'll come to the end of it up here on Carmel.'
'What has happened?' the monk asked in his careful English. 'Nothing terrible, I trust?'
'Bad enough,' snapped the policeman, grimly. 'An English officer shot dead near Athlit, and a couple of Englishwomen badly wounded. We got there 20 minutes after the shooting occurred, and my dogs picked up a fresh scent at once. We've been following it now for 7 hours, and as soon as we're rested a bit we must push on. I only hope that the murdering devils belong to some village up here and have not doubled all the way round just to throw us off the trail. There's no help for it, though, we've got to follow their trail whichever way they went.'
'How terrible,' said the monk, aghast. 'The officer, you say, is dead? And the ladies, are they in any danger?'
'Yes, he's dead,' they answered. 'His wife is only slightly wounded, but the other lady has had several bullet-wounds. I don't know if there is any hope for her, but she looked pretty bad when I saw her being put into the ambulance.'" (p 50)
Our farmer enquires as to whether the dogs "get good results":
'Yes,' he replied, 'on the whole we are fairly successful. Recently a very famous man, Starkey the archaeologist who unearthed Lachish, was murdered by an armed gang. The dogs led us straight to the house of one of the killers, and the criminal confessed his guilt before he was executed.'
'You've got a pretty dangerous job, haven't you?' I asked. 'I don't mean only at the end of your hunts when you've got the vermin bottled up, but from murder attempts when you're off duty.'
'They certainly don't like us,' he answered with a grin. 'These 'wogs' would very much like to see me planted in Bishop Gobat's cemetery on Mount Zion.'
'I asked him who on earth, or what on earth, were 'wogs', and made the discovery that this is the generic term used by British Police and military for all non-Jewish Palestinians - Jews were simply 'Yids', or 'Ikey-Mo's', generally the former, though they were also referred to as 'Four-by-Two's'." (pp 51-2)
Despite the reservations of the patrol, our farmer is allowed to join the hunt:
"As an ordinary plain Englishman my blood was afire for vengeance. The herd instinct, perhaps. Someone had injured members of my own herd; the murderers were coloured men, and therefore had added sheer impertinence to their callous killing. To be perfectly honest, their impudence in daring to strike at one of the sacrosanct whites was worse, in our estimation, than the fact of murder. Of course not one of us, officers, soldiers, nor myself, admitted or, perhaps fully realized that point. We believed ourselves charged with extremely righteous indignation - so did some of the people who burned Joan of Arc." (p 54)
On and on they plough, eventually nearing a Palestinian village:
"The police officer spoke. 'We are close to the village of Ijzim,' he said. 'I thought that the trail would lead somewhere near to Haifa, though I expected that we should be taken to Tireh down on the plain. You know the orders, don't you? Surround the place, challenge anyone attempting to leave, and shoot to kill if they refuse to halt. I'll need an escort to enter the houses to which we are led. Now let's get started, the sooner this is over the better.' He turned to me. 'You'd better stay outside the village in the cordon, for you never know what these brutes will do when they are cornered.'
The military officers issued their instructions to their men, and I saw a new freshness come into the weary faces. I felt that way myself. We were at the end of the hunt - the foxes had gone to ground just ahead - brittle excitement crisped the air.
A few hundred yards farther on we came into sight of the little village, a poverty-stricken place of small stone houses. We must have taken the villagers completely by surprise, for we were quite close, and had a small section of soldiers working round to the far side, before any alarm was raised.
A few Arabs ran into houses. With mad eagerness our men pressed on, their rifles ready, fingers on their triggers.
Suddenly an Arab came running from the cover of the houses, racing, with head up and legs going like pistons, as he made a frantic dash for the shelter of the scrub-covered hillside. A dozen British voices, aided by some of the Arab police, yelled and shouted at him to halt, but he took no notice except to put on a further spurt, and to drive his body forward with redoubled speed and stress of energy.
Two or three rifles crashed, one so close behind me that I thought my ear-drums were split. The fugitive seemed to leap a yard high, then he stumbled, recovered his feet, and started to run again - another rifle shot. The poor devil bounded upright, his head snapped back as his spine curved, and down he went in a smashing tumble. For a moment or two his heels beat a mad tattoo on the rocky earth until, with a convulsive jerk, he grew still. I had seen a man killed by intentional violence - all the excitement and mad exaltation ran out of me like water out of a cracked firkin, leaving me deathly sick for pity of it all.
We ran forward to the limp, prostrate figure. A police constable turned him over - he was quite dead - and searched amongst his clothes. The man looked very disappointed as he ended his search.
'The -- hasn't got a gun, sir,' he growled. 'Not even a -- dagger. 'Ullo, wot's this?' He groped about for a second, and then with the utmost satisfaction produced two empty brass cartridge-cases. 'Ere y'are, sir,' he went on in triumph, 'hexpended cartridges. 'E must be one of the bastards wot shot the officer and the two wimmen.'
My God! That was supposed to be evidence. Arabs will always pick up empty cartridge-cases for the value of the brass, which their village smiths will make up into ornaments or use to cover their dagger-sheaths - or refill them on their home-made cartridge presses. The dead man might have been one of the murderers - that can never be proved or disproved now, but, seeing that he had no weapon whatsoever, naught but these two empty cases, there seemed to be little enough evidence. True, he had run away, but that was proof of nothing but an uneasy conscience. He may have been guilty of some other offence, and ran because he thought the patrol had come for him. Or he might really have been one of the murdering gang. In any case, he has suffered the fate of the guilty. He is dead - and therefore far wiser than any of us who saw him shot down like a bolting rabbit." (pp 56-8)
***
"There is not much more to tell. The murderers' trail led to two houses; they were not in residence. A message was sent into Haifa. More troops and police arrived, and the village of Ijzim was 'put to the question' in the strictest sense. Later, a party of Royal Engineers made their appearance, and two houses, those to which the dogs had led the patrol, went soaring and rocketing into the clear air, torn apart by the thundering blast of the explosion detonated by the Sappers.
I had read of a Roman Peace - of making a desolation and calling it peace; I now saw what it meant. I am not saying Ijzim men had not taken part in the ambush on the car, most probably some of them had done so, but that seemed a very poor excuse for ruthlessly destroying two homes, for sending women and little children into destitution. Still less for what followed, the collective fining of everyone in the village; and, because the poor devils could not pay, for seizing their small, pitiful flocks and herds and driving them away to be sold.
I may be too imaginative, but I rather put myself in the places of these poor villagers, probably because they are just farmers like myself. Let us suppose that we had an Asiatic army-of-occupation in Dorset, and that they were there to foist negro colonizers on us to farm our downlands on terms that were more favourable than any which we could obtain. Let us imagine that some of our youngsters objected; that, in sheer desperation, they turned out and shot some of the Asiatics; that they were then hunted by dogs; that yellow-faced, slit-eyed foreigners surrounded, say, Cerne Abbas in Dorset, shot one of the leading farmer's sons because he failed to halt; and, finally, suppose that two of our farmhouses were blown up by the foreign Engineers, and all our stock was seized. Try to imagine what we should feel, and then make some attempt to understand what the Arabs think of us. The analogy is complete. Because we had been driven desperate, deliberately driven desperate, we turned on our tyrants in despair - to be mercilessly punished for what we had been driven to do and then left to starve in our destitution because our means of livelihood was snatched away." (pp 59-60)
[*See my 21/3/11 post Jogging Uri Avnery's Memory.]
What follows is part of his story as told by British writer Douglas V. Duff in his book, Palestine Unveiled (1938). The event described was a mere blip in the great Palestine Revolt of 1936-1939, when the Palestinian people rose up against the British Mandate authorities' attempt to transform their homeland, through mass immigration of European Jews and Jewish land purchases, into a National Home for something called 'the Jewish people'.* It's a tale that spans some 16 pages in the original, but I've reduced it somewhat by omitting parts of Duff's text and replacing them with brief, linking summaries. Oh, and another thing: you'll notice as you read that the British war crimes committed against the Palestinians in the 30s are today routinely committed by their Israeli apprentices:
Our farmer is visiting a monastery on Mt Carmel, overlooking the coastal city of Haifa when his conversation with one of its monks, Father Elias, is suddenly interrupted:
"Fra Elias talked away, giving me the details of the view, and I turned from one to the other, recognizing how aptly the historical narrative of the Bible fitted into it all, when there was a sudden shouting in the dip below the peak upon which the monastery stands. We stood up and looked in that direction; in a few minutes some very tired and blown British soldiers and police came toiling up the steep path to the monastery door. A man in civilian clothes, tweed shooting-jacket, breeches and khaki shirt, was holding two dogs. He, with a couple of uniformed officers, came up to us as we stepped to the door.
'Good evening, Father,' said one officer, who had a couple of metal stars on the shoulder-straps of his tunic, 'we're sorry to bother you, but I wonder if you could let us have some hot water to make tea? The men are pretty nearly all in, but with some hot tea, and a rest, they will get their second wind.'" (p 48)
Father Elias obliges and the following conversation ensues:
"'You look very tired, gentlemen,' said Fra Elias. 'We have several bedrooms. We could arrange quarters for you and your men. Will you not stay the night?'
'Sorry, Father, said the police-officer. 'I wish we could, but we've got to push on. The trail's hot, and with a bit of luck we'll come to the end of it up here on Carmel.'
'What has happened?' the monk asked in his careful English. 'Nothing terrible, I trust?'
'Bad enough,' snapped the policeman, grimly. 'An English officer shot dead near Athlit, and a couple of Englishwomen badly wounded. We got there 20 minutes after the shooting occurred, and my dogs picked up a fresh scent at once. We've been following it now for 7 hours, and as soon as we're rested a bit we must push on. I only hope that the murdering devils belong to some village up here and have not doubled all the way round just to throw us off the trail. There's no help for it, though, we've got to follow their trail whichever way they went.'
'How terrible,' said the monk, aghast. 'The officer, you say, is dead? And the ladies, are they in any danger?'
'Yes, he's dead,' they answered. 'His wife is only slightly wounded, but the other lady has had several bullet-wounds. I don't know if there is any hope for her, but she looked pretty bad when I saw her being put into the ambulance.'" (p 50)
Our farmer enquires as to whether the dogs "get good results":
'Yes,' he replied, 'on the whole we are fairly successful. Recently a very famous man, Starkey the archaeologist who unearthed Lachish, was murdered by an armed gang. The dogs led us straight to the house of one of the killers, and the criminal confessed his guilt before he was executed.'
'You've got a pretty dangerous job, haven't you?' I asked. 'I don't mean only at the end of your hunts when you've got the vermin bottled up, but from murder attempts when you're off duty.'
'They certainly don't like us,' he answered with a grin. 'These 'wogs' would very much like to see me planted in Bishop Gobat's cemetery on Mount Zion.'
'I asked him who on earth, or what on earth, were 'wogs', and made the discovery that this is the generic term used by British Police and military for all non-Jewish Palestinians - Jews were simply 'Yids', or 'Ikey-Mo's', generally the former, though they were also referred to as 'Four-by-Two's'." (pp 51-2)
Despite the reservations of the patrol, our farmer is allowed to join the hunt:
"As an ordinary plain Englishman my blood was afire for vengeance. The herd instinct, perhaps. Someone had injured members of my own herd; the murderers were coloured men, and therefore had added sheer impertinence to their callous killing. To be perfectly honest, their impudence in daring to strike at one of the sacrosanct whites was worse, in our estimation, than the fact of murder. Of course not one of us, officers, soldiers, nor myself, admitted or, perhaps fully realized that point. We believed ourselves charged with extremely righteous indignation - so did some of the people who burned Joan of Arc." (p 54)
On and on they plough, eventually nearing a Palestinian village:
"The police officer spoke. 'We are close to the village of Ijzim,' he said. 'I thought that the trail would lead somewhere near to Haifa, though I expected that we should be taken to Tireh down on the plain. You know the orders, don't you? Surround the place, challenge anyone attempting to leave, and shoot to kill if they refuse to halt. I'll need an escort to enter the houses to which we are led. Now let's get started, the sooner this is over the better.' He turned to me. 'You'd better stay outside the village in the cordon, for you never know what these brutes will do when they are cornered.'
The military officers issued their instructions to their men, and I saw a new freshness come into the weary faces. I felt that way myself. We were at the end of the hunt - the foxes had gone to ground just ahead - brittle excitement crisped the air.
A few hundred yards farther on we came into sight of the little village, a poverty-stricken place of small stone houses. We must have taken the villagers completely by surprise, for we were quite close, and had a small section of soldiers working round to the far side, before any alarm was raised.
A few Arabs ran into houses. With mad eagerness our men pressed on, their rifles ready, fingers on their triggers.
Suddenly an Arab came running from the cover of the houses, racing, with head up and legs going like pistons, as he made a frantic dash for the shelter of the scrub-covered hillside. A dozen British voices, aided by some of the Arab police, yelled and shouted at him to halt, but he took no notice except to put on a further spurt, and to drive his body forward with redoubled speed and stress of energy.
Two or three rifles crashed, one so close behind me that I thought my ear-drums were split. The fugitive seemed to leap a yard high, then he stumbled, recovered his feet, and started to run again - another rifle shot. The poor devil bounded upright, his head snapped back as his spine curved, and down he went in a smashing tumble. For a moment or two his heels beat a mad tattoo on the rocky earth until, with a convulsive jerk, he grew still. I had seen a man killed by intentional violence - all the excitement and mad exaltation ran out of me like water out of a cracked firkin, leaving me deathly sick for pity of it all.
We ran forward to the limp, prostrate figure. A police constable turned him over - he was quite dead - and searched amongst his clothes. The man looked very disappointed as he ended his search.
'The -- hasn't got a gun, sir,' he growled. 'Not even a -- dagger. 'Ullo, wot's this?' He groped about for a second, and then with the utmost satisfaction produced two empty brass cartridge-cases. 'Ere y'are, sir,' he went on in triumph, 'hexpended cartridges. 'E must be one of the bastards wot shot the officer and the two wimmen.'
My God! That was supposed to be evidence. Arabs will always pick up empty cartridge-cases for the value of the brass, which their village smiths will make up into ornaments or use to cover their dagger-sheaths - or refill them on their home-made cartridge presses. The dead man might have been one of the murderers - that can never be proved or disproved now, but, seeing that he had no weapon whatsoever, naught but these two empty cases, there seemed to be little enough evidence. True, he had run away, but that was proof of nothing but an uneasy conscience. He may have been guilty of some other offence, and ran because he thought the patrol had come for him. Or he might really have been one of the murdering gang. In any case, he has suffered the fate of the guilty. He is dead - and therefore far wiser than any of us who saw him shot down like a bolting rabbit." (pp 56-8)
***
"There is not much more to tell. The murderers' trail led to two houses; they were not in residence. A message was sent into Haifa. More troops and police arrived, and the village of Ijzim was 'put to the question' in the strictest sense. Later, a party of Royal Engineers made their appearance, and two houses, those to which the dogs had led the patrol, went soaring and rocketing into the clear air, torn apart by the thundering blast of the explosion detonated by the Sappers.
I had read of a Roman Peace - of making a desolation and calling it peace; I now saw what it meant. I am not saying Ijzim men had not taken part in the ambush on the car, most probably some of them had done so, but that seemed a very poor excuse for ruthlessly destroying two homes, for sending women and little children into destitution. Still less for what followed, the collective fining of everyone in the village; and, because the poor devils could not pay, for seizing their small, pitiful flocks and herds and driving them away to be sold.
I may be too imaginative, but I rather put myself in the places of these poor villagers, probably because they are just farmers like myself. Let us suppose that we had an Asiatic army-of-occupation in Dorset, and that they were there to foist negro colonizers on us to farm our downlands on terms that were more favourable than any which we could obtain. Let us imagine that some of our youngsters objected; that, in sheer desperation, they turned out and shot some of the Asiatics; that they were then hunted by dogs; that yellow-faced, slit-eyed foreigners surrounded, say, Cerne Abbas in Dorset, shot one of the leading farmer's sons because he failed to halt; and, finally, suppose that two of our farmhouses were blown up by the foreign Engineers, and all our stock was seized. Try to imagine what we should feel, and then make some attempt to understand what the Arabs think of us. The analogy is complete. Because we had been driven desperate, deliberately driven desperate, we turned on our tyrants in despair - to be mercilessly punished for what we had been driven to do and then left to starve in our destitution because our means of livelihood was snatched away." (pp 59-60)
[*See my 21/3/11 post Jogging Uri Avnery's Memory.]
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)