Perpetual Nakba

The Israeli ethnic cleansing of Palestinians that began with the Nakba (Catastrophe) of 1948, celebrated by Israel and its affiliates around the world as Independence (from Palestinians?) Day, just keeps on keeping on.

An absolute must-read for today - Nakba Day - from Haaretz journalist Gideon Levy:

"It happened on the day after Independence Day, when Israel was immersed in praise of itself and its democracy ad nauseum, and on the eve of (virtually outlawed) Nakba Day, when the Palestinian people mark the 'catastrophe' - the anniversary of the creation of Israel. My colleague Akiva Eldar published what we have always known but for which we lacked the shocking figures he has revealed: By the time of the Oslo Accords, Israel had revoked the residency of 140,000 Palestinians from the West Bank. In other words, 14% of West Bank residents who dared to go abroad had their right of return to Israel and live here denied forever. In other words, they were expelled from their land and their homes. In other words: ethnic cleansing.

"While we are still desperately concealing, denying and repressing our major ethnic cleansing of 1948 - over 600,000 refugees, some who fled for fear of the Israel Defense Forces and its predecessors, some who were expelled by force - it turns out that 1948 never ended, that its spirit is still with us. Also with us is the goal of trying to cleanse this land of its Arab inhabitants as much as possible, and even a bit more. After all, that's the most covert and desired solution: the Land of Israel for the Jews, for them alone. A few people dared to say it outright - Rabbi Meir Kahane, Minister Rehavam Ze'evi and their disciples, who deserve a certain amount of praise for their integrity. Many aspire to do the same thing without admitting it.

"The revelation of the policy of denying residency has proved that this secret dream is in effect the establishment's secret dream. There one doesn't talk about transfer, heaven forfend; nobody would think of calling it cleansing. They don't load Arabs onto trucks as they once did, including after the Six-Day War, and they don't shoot at them to chase them away - all politically incorrect methods in the new world. But in effect that's the goal.

"Some people think it's enough if we make the lives of the Palestinians in the territories miserable to get them to leave, and many have in fact left. An Israeli success: According to the Civil Administration, about a quarter of a million Palestinians involuntarily left the West Bank in the bloody years 2000-2007. But that's not enough, so various and sundry administrative means were added to make the dream come true.

"Anyone who says 'it's not apartheid' is invited to reply: Why is an Israeli allowed to leave his country for the rest of his life, and nobody suggests that his citizenship be revoked, while a Palestinian, a native son, is not allowed to do so? Why is an Israeli allowed to marry a foreigner and receive a residency permit for her, while a Palestinian is not allowed to marry his former neighbor who lives in Jordan? Isn't that apartheid? Over the years I have documented endless pitiful tragedies of families that were torn apart, whose sons and daughters were not permitted to live in the West Bank or Gaza due to draconian rules - for Palestinians only.

"Take Dalal Rasras, for example, a toddler with cerebral palsy from Beit Omar, who was recently separated from her mother for months only because her mother was born in Rafah. Only after her case was publicized did Israel let the mother return to her daughter 'beyond the letter of the law' - the cruel letter of the law that does not permit residents of Gaza to live in the West Bank, even if they have made their homes there.

"The cry of the dispossessed has now translated into numbers: 140,000, only until the Oslo Accords. Students who went to study at foreign universities, businessmen who tried their luck abroad, scientists who went abroad for professional training, native Jerusalemites who dared to move to the West Bank temporarily - they all met the same fate. All of them were taken by the wind and expelled by Israel. They couldn't return.

"Most amazing of all is the reaction of those responsible for the policy of ethnic cleansing. They didn't know. Maj. Gen. (res.) Danny Rothschild, formerly the chief military governor with the euphemistic title 'coordinator of government activities in the territories', said he heard about the procedure for the first time from Haaretz. It turns out that not only is the cleansing continuing, so is the denial. Every Palestinian child knows, and only the general doesn't. Even today there are still 130,000 Palestinians registered as 'NLR', a heartwarming IDF acronym for 'no longer a resident', as though voluntarily, another euphemism for 'expelled'. And the general who is considered relatively enlightened was unaware.

"This is an absolute refusal to allow the return of the refugees - something that would 'destroy the State of Israel'. It's also an absolute refusal to allow the return of the people recently expelled. By next Independence Day we'll probably invent more expulsion regulations, and on the next holiday we'll talk about 'the only democracy'." (12/5/11)